SIGNED BOARD REPORTX��"���MONTEREY COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
MEETING: July 27, 2010 AGENDA NO:
SUBJECT: Consider adoption of a resolution denying the appeal by Wayne Holman for Aromas
Heritage Oaks LLC from the Planning Commission's denial of a Combined Development Permit
Aromas Heritage Oaks; PLN980503) consisting of. Standard Subdivision to divide
approximately 79.5 acres into 32 parcels ranging in size from 1.0 acres to 15.91 acres, including
one lot Lot 32) with four inclusionary rental units; Use Permit for removal of approximately 367
protected oak trees 271 for roads and up to 96 on the individual lots); Use Permit for four
inclusionary rental units; and grading approximately 5,100 cubic yards cut and 5,100 cubic yards
fill. PLN980503/Aromas Heritage Oaks LLC, North County Area Plan)
Project Location: Easterly of San Juan Road, approximately 600 267-123-031-000
feet southerly of the intersection of San Juan APN: and
Road and Aromas Road at the terminus of Rea 267-051-014-000
Avenue
Planning Number: PLN980503 Name: Aromas Heritage
Oaks LLC
Plan Area: North County
Zoning Designation: LDR 2.5 Low Density Residential, 2.5 Flagged
acres/unit) and
No
CEQA Action: No Action Required, Public Resources Code Staked:
Section 21080(b)(5); CEQA Guidelines
Section 15061(b)(4)
DEPARTMENT: RMA Planning Department
RECOMMENDATION:
Per the Board's direction, staff has prepared a resolution Exhibit A) denying the appeal by
Wayne Holman for Aromas Heritage Oaks LLC from the Planning Commission's denial of a
Combined Development Permit Aromas Heritage Oaks; PLN980503) consisting of. Standard
Subdivision to divide approximately 79.5 acres into 32 parcels ranging in size from 1.0 acres to
15.91 acres, including one lot Lot 32) with four inclusionary rental units; Use Permit for
removal of approximately 367 protected oak trees 271 for roads and up to 96 on the individual
lots); Use Permit for four inclusionary rental units; and grading approximately 5,100 cubic yards
cut and 5,100 cubic yards fill).
SUMMARY:
The Board of Supervisors held a public hearing on the appeal and above-described application
for a Combined Development Permit on June 15, 2010, following continuances of the hearings
from prior dates. At the close of the hearing on June 15, the Board adopted a Resolution of
Intent to deny the appeal and continued the matter to July 27 with direction to staff to prepare a
resolution with findings and evidence for denial. Staff has prepared the attached resolution
Exhibit A) for the Board's consideration.
FINANCING:
Funding for staff time associated with this project is included as part of the application and
appeal fees collected for this project.
BIB]
40394-U01
SIGNED-U02
BOARD-U02
REPORT-U02
LI21329-U03
FO21330-U03
FO85769-U03
FO89518-U03
MG89556-U03
AS89575-U03
AS89581-U03
AI93235-U03
DO94057-U03
C10-U03
BOARD-U03
REPORTS-U03
8/4/2010-U04
RIVASR-U04
15305-U05
1-U06
CONSIDER-U07
ADOPTION-U07
OF-U07
RESOLUTION-U07
DENYING-U07
APPEAL-U07
BY-U07
WAYNE-U07
HOLMAN-U07
AROMAS-U07
HERITAGE-U07
OAKS-U07
LLC-U07
293-P&BI-U08
ROTHARMEL-U09
LINDA-U09
ROTHARMELL-U10
7/12/2010-U011
PLANNING-U012
COMMISSION-U012
S-U012
DENIAL-U012
OF-U012
A-U012
COMBINED-U012
DEVELOPMENT-U012
PERMIT-U012
AROMAS-U012
HERITAGE-U012
OAKS;-U012
PLN980503)-U012
CONSISTING-U012
OF:-U012
STANDARD-U012
SUBDIVISION-U012
TO-U012
DIVIDE-U012
APPROXIMATELY-U012
79.5-U012
ACRES-U012
INTO-U012
32-U012
PARCELS-U012
RANGING-U012
IN-U012
SIZE-U012
1.0-U012
ACRES-U012
TO-U012
15.91-U012
ACRES,-U012
INCLUDING-U012
ONE-U012
LOT-U012
LOT-U012
32)-U012
FOUR-U012
INCLUSIONARY-U012
RENTAL-U012
UNITS;-U012
USE-U012
PERMIT-U012
REMOVAL-U012
OF-U012
APPROXIMATELY-U012
367-U012
PROTECTED-U012
OAK-U012
TREES-U012
271-U012
ROADS-U012
UP-U012
TO-U012
96-U012
ON-U012
INDIVIDUAL-U012
LOTS);-U012
USE-U012
PERMIT-U012
FOUR-U012
INCLUSIONARY-U012
RENTAL-U012
UNITS;-U012
GRADING-U012
APPROXIMATELY-U012
5,100-U012
CUBIC-U012
YARDS-U012
CUT-U012
5,100-U012
CUBIC-U012
YARDS-U012
FILL.-U012
PLN980503/AROMAS-U012
HERITAGE-U012
OAKS-U012
LLC,-U012
NORTH-U012
COUNTY-U012
AREA-U012
PLAN)-U012
SIGNED BOARD REPORTX��"���Prepared by:
Bob Schubert, AICP, Senior Planner
755-5183; schubertbj@co.monterey.ca.us
cc:
Approved by:
Alana Knaster, Deputy Director, RMA
Front Counter Copy; Board of Supervisor's 16); County Counsel; Aromas Tri County Fire Protection
District; Public Works Department; Parks Department; Housing and Redevelopment Agency;
Environmental Health Division; Water Resources Agency; Alana Knaster, Assistant Director, RMA
Department, Mike Novo, Planning Director, Carl Holm, Assistant Planning Director; Wendy Stremling,
County Counsel; Leslie Gerard, County Counsel; Vicki Morris, Aromas Water District; Pajaro Valley
Water Management District; Bob Schubert, Project Planner; Carol Allen, Senior Secretary; Wayne
Holman, Owner; Derinda Messenger, Agent; John Bridges, Agent; Fumi Kimura, Bob Bugalski, Molly
Erickson via e-mail); Jennifer Holda via e-mail); Rona Gertzulin Sowash via e-mail); Cathy Miller
via e-mail); Marjorie Kay via e-mail); George Mortan via e-mail); Carolyn Anderson via e-mail);
Carol Hughes via e-mail); Margie Western via e-mail); Addie Bakich via e-mail); Jack McKenzie
via e-mail); Greg Albertson via e-mail); Dianne Russell via e-mail); Henry Gowin via e-mail);
Planning File PLN980503.
Exhibit A Draft Resolution
2
BIB]
40394-U01
SIGNED-U02
BOARD-U02
REPORT-U02
LI21329-U03
FO21330-U03
FO85769-U03
FO89518-U03
MG89556-U03
AS89575-U03
AS89581-U03
AI93235-U03
DO94057-U03
C10-U03
BOARD-U03
REPORTS-U03
8/4/2010-U04
RIVASR-U04
15305-U05
1-U06
CONSIDER-U07
ADOPTION-U07
OF-U07
RESOLUTION-U07
DENYING-U07
APPEAL-U07
BY-U07
WAYNE-U07
HOLMAN-U07
AROMAS-U07
HERITAGE-U07
OAKS-U07
LLC-U07
293-P&BI-U08
ROTHARMEL-U09
LINDA-U09
ROTHARMELL-U10
7/12/2010-U011
PLANNING-U012
COMMISSION-U012
S-U012
DENIAL-U012
OF-U012
A-U012
COMBINED-U012
DEVELOPMENT-U012
PERMIT-U012
AROMAS-U012
HERITAGE-U012
OAKS;-U012
PLN980503)-U012
CONSISTING-U012
OF:-U012
STANDARD-U012
SUBDIVISION-U012
TO-U012
DIVIDE-U012
APPROXIMATELY-U012
79.5-U012
ACRES-U012
INTO-U012
32-U012
PARCELS-U012
RANGING-U012
IN-U012
SIZE-U012
1.0-U012
ACRES-U012
TO-U012
15.91-U012
ACRES,-U012
INCLUDING-U012
ONE-U012
LOT-U012
LOT-U012
32)-U012
FOUR-U012
INCLUSIONARY-U012
RENTAL-U012
UNITS;-U012
USE-U012
PERMIT-U012
REMOVAL-U012
OF-U012
APPROXIMATELY-U012
367-U012
PROTECTED-U012
OAK-U012
TREES-U012
271-U012
ROADS-U012
UP-U012
TO-U012
96-U012
ON-U012
INDIVIDUAL-U012
LOTS);-U012
USE-U012
PERMIT-U012
FOUR-U012
INCLUSIONARY-U012
RENTAL-U012
UNITS;-U012
GRADING-U012
APPROXIMATELY-U012
5,100-U012
CUBIC-U012
YARDS-U012
CUT-U012
5,100-U012
CUBIC-U012
YARDS-U012
FILL.-U012
PLN980503/AROMAS-U012
HERITAGE-U012
OAKS-U012
LLC,-U012
NORTH-U012
COUNTY-U012
AREA-U012
PLAN)-U012