Title
PLN250292 - SIGNAL HILL LLC
Continued from October 27, 2026 - Public Hearing to:
a. Consider the appeal of Sam and Betsy Reeves of the Chief of Planning’s July 27, 2026 decision to approval a Combined Development Permit;
b. Consider the construction of an attached 774 square foot Accessory Dwelling Unit, development within 100 feet of Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Area, development on slopes in excess of 30 percent, and development within 750 feet of a known archaeological resource.
Project Location: 1170 Signal Hill Road, Pebble Beach
Proposed CEQA action: Find the project Categorically Exempt pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15303, and there are no exceptions pursuant to Section 15300.2.
Body
RECOMMENDATION:
It is recommended that the Board of Supervisors adopt a resolution to:
a. Deny the appeal of Sam and Betsy Reeves of the Chief of Planning’s approval of the Combined Development Permit;
b. Find that the project qualifies for a Categorical Exemption pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15303 and no exceptions pursuant to section 15300.2 can be made; and
c. Approve a Combined Development Permit consisting of:
i. Coastal Administrative Permit and Design Approval to allow construction of a 774 square foot attached Accessory Dwelling Unit and associated site improvements;
ii. Coastal Development Permit for development within 100 feet of environmentally sensitive habitat;
iii. Coastal Administrative Permit for development within 750 feet of a known archaeological resource; and
iv. Coastal Administrative Permit to allow development on slopes in excess of 30 percent.
The attached draft resolution includes findings and evidence for consideration (Exhibit B). Staff recommends approval of the project subject to 9 conditions of approval.
PROJECT INFORMATION:
Agent: Massy Mehdipour
Property Owner: Signal Hill LLC
APN: 008-261-007-000
Parcel Size: 2.19 acres or 95, 396 square feet
Zoning: Low Density Residential with 1.5 acres per unit density, Design Control overlay in the Coastal Zone or “LDR/1.5-D(CZ)”
Plan Area: Del Monte Forest Land Use Plan
Flagged and Staked: Yes
Project Planner: McKenna Bowling, Associate Planner
bowlingmr@countyofmonterey.gov, (831) 755-5298
SUMMARY:
The subject property is located at 1170 Signal Hill Road, within Pebble Beach. The lot is currently undeveloped, however, the subject parcel was approved for construction of a single-family dwelling through PLN240077 and PLN100338 (Board of Supervisor Resolution Nos. 23-237 and 25-334). The Applicant has obtained construction permits (25CP04088) for this work.
On July 27, 2026, the Chief of Planning approved a Combined Development Permit (PLN250292; Chief of Planning Resolution No. 26-061; Attachment C) consisting of 1) Coastal Administrative Permit and Design Approval to allow construction of a 798 square foot attached Accessory Dwelling Unit and associated site improvements, including 220 square feet of porches and terraces and a lower-level unconditioned crawl space; and 2) Coastal Development Permit to allow development within 100 feet of Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Area; and 3) Coastal Administrative Permit to allow development within 750 feet of a known archeological resource; and 4) Coastal Development Permit to allow development on slopes in excess of 30 percent; and 5) Coastal Development Permit to remove and relocate one Monterey Cypress tree.
The appellants, Sam and Betsy Reeves (Appellants), represented by the Law Offices of Tony Lobardo, timely appealed the July 27, 2026, decision approving the Combined Development Permit. The Appellant contends that the Chief of Planning’s decision was not supported by the evidence and that the decision is contrary to law (Attachment B). Appellants’ specific contentions are identified below and addressed in more detail in the Draft Resolution (Attachment A).
The original project scope was scheduled for consideration by the Board of Supervisors on September 29, 2026, and was continued to October 27, 2026 to allow the applicant time to provide revised project materials. On October 27, 2026, the hearing was continued to November 17, 2026, to allow the applicant additional time to provide revised project materials that better comply with County Code. The Applicants now propose construction of a 774 square foot ADU that has been reconfigured to be primarily within the prior driveway footprint, thereby minimizing impacts on the environment. The revised project scope no longer requires the removal of a Cypress tree, and has reduced development on slopes to 112 square feet. The project continues to be within 100 feet of environmentally sensitive habitat areas and 750 feet of known archaeological resources. The proposed grading quantities to construct the ADU include 60 cubic yards of cut and 30 cubic yards of fill, with a net export of 30 cubic yards.
Staff have reviewed the revised project scope and believes it better complies with the goals, policies, and text of Monterey County Code and the Local Coastal Program. Staff recommends the Board of Supervisors deny the appeal and approve the Combined Development Permit.
APPEAL
The appeal raises numerous potential issues with the project. (Attachment B). Staff has grouped these contentions as follows:
1) “The findings and evidence of Resolution 26-061 are several pages long and contain a substantial number of examples where the evidence does not support the conclusion and resulting decision.”
2) “…despite the Board's decision to not allow the tree to be removed and the applicant's assurance to the Board the Cypress tree would be protected, the applicant wants to remove and "relocate" that same tree for the ADU. The proposed removal and relocation would eliminate the last vestige of the promised screening of the new house from 17 Mile Drive as promised by the applicant. there will be no visual screening of the home.”
3) “The project is much larger than a 798 SF ADU. The structure is nearly 2,000 SF. Any environmental assessment which does not address the potential impacts of the project as a whole, as required by CEQA, is inadequate.”
4) “The State law and County ordinance are clear, the Coastal Act takes precent over other State and location regulations, including regulations for ADUs.”
5) “The Board of Supervisors approved demolition of the Connell House (PLN100338), a significant historic resource listed on both the State and Federal registers, subject to a subsequent design approval (PLN240077). That approval is (PLN100338) is very specific in its choice and implementation of FEIR Alternative 6 as mitigation of the loss of the Connell House. The approval limits development to the Connell House's "historic footprint.” and “The proposed project is inconsistent with the Board’s direction (Resolution 23-237 and Resolution 25-132) for the location and size of the allowable development on the site.”
6) “There is no evidence in the record of biological resources that may or may not have been on-site when the application was filed. To the best of my knowledge, the County has never relied on a 15-year-old biological report to approve development in Coastal ESHA.”
7) “There would be ample room in the area already cleared of resources by the demolition of the remainder of the Connell House to accommodate an ADU, without development on 30% slopes, remnant dunes or removal of the last of the remaining tree screening the view of the home from 17 Mile Drive.”
Appellants’ contentions #1 and #7 do correctly raise issues with the original project’s compliance with the County’s Local Coastal Program. The original project scope did not fully explore alternative designs that would avoid impact on coastal resources. However, the Applicant has since revised the project scope to better comply with the goals and policies of the Local Coastal Program. Specifically, the revised project scope avoids tree removal, minimizes grading of native steeper slopes, and assures protection of the public views. The remaining contentions of the appeal (#2 through #6) are not supported by evidence, are contrary to law, and/or have no merit. Therefore, staff recommends denial of the appeal. Detailed responses to above contentions are provided in more detail in the draft Resolution (Attachment A).
Site Suitability, Steeper Slopes, Forest Resources
The Appellants assert that the selected development site is not suitable for the proposed project because of both its design and potential impact on the public viewshed.
The project includes construction of an attached 774 square foot ADU, rather than the larger 798 square foot ADU previously proposed. The majority of the property will be restricted by a Conservation and Scenic Easement (CSE), as required by Policy 13 of the DMF LUP, leaving limited areas suitable for development of an accessory structure. As designed and sited, the ADU will be structurally connected to the previously approved residence (yet to be constructed). The proposed ADU location and floorplan configuration reduces the likelihood of blocking public views by consolidating the property’s development footprint to one area. These design elements comply with site development standards, and minimize impacts to on-site resource constraints, such as nearby trees, steeper slopes, and ESHA.
The Del Monte Forest LUAC and HCD-Planning staff have determined that the architectural design of the ADU is compatible with the surrounding area, as it matches the previously approved residence and would have minimal impacts on the public viewshed once the main residence was constructed. Multiple reports have been prepared for the project determining the suitability of the site for the project, and evaluating potential impacts as a result of construction.
In comparison to the original design, the revised project scope reduces the needed development on slopes to 112 square feet and avoids tree removal. These 112 square feet of development on steeper slopes is the only portion of the proposed project that is sited outside of prior development footprints (including driveway improvements). However, these 112 square feet of development on steeper slopes is located within the grading limits of the previously approved single family dwelling application. The previously approved single family dwelling application (Board of Supervisors Resolutions No. 23-237 and 25-334; HCD-Planning File Nos. PLN100338 and PLN240077) included a Coastal Development Permit to allow grading and development on slopes in excess of 30%.
The Applicant argues that a Coastal Development Permit to allow development on steeper (>30%) slopes is not required for the ADU because the main residence project included a Coastal Development Permit to allow grading in this area covers. Although the proposed ADU does not involve additional development on slopes in excess of 30% that has not been previously contemplated or approved, the approved grading has yet to occur in that area as of November 1, 2026. Therefore steeper slopes still exist that require the granting of a discretionary permit. Title 20 section 20.64.230.C.2(d) only requires the granting of a Coastal Administrative Permit if less than 120 square feet of development is proposed on slopes for projects that involve additions to structures. Accordingly, a Coastal Development Permit is not required in this case, only a Coastal Administrative Permit, which does not require the finding that feasible alternatives be explored to reduce development on steeper slopes.
Additionally, as indicated in the plans, the proposed project avoids native tree removal. The project design was revised to retain nearby Cypress trees that are protected under the DMF LUP. Therefore, the project will have no impact on native trees, and complies with the forest resource protection policies of the LUP, that require development to incorporate design measures to minimize tree removal. Nearby trees shall be protected in place for the duration of all ground disturbing activities. As conditioned, special protection measures stall be taken to ensure that grading of the sandy soils will not undermine nearby trees. As proposed, designed, and conditioned, the project is consistent with Policy 33’s directive to minimize tree removal and soil disturbance through project design, and Policy 35 because it avoids removal of forest resources that contribute to the visual character of a public view corridor. Therefore, no Coastal Development Permit to allow tree removal is needed in this case.
Therefore, when considering the site’s constraints (including setbacks, pending conservation easements, etc.), nearby coastal resources, and the previously approved development, staff has concluded that the revised scope of the proposed ADU does comply with required Local Coastal Program requirements to minimize, and where feasible, avoid impacts to coastal resources, including trees and steeper slopes.
Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Area
According to the Final Environmental Impact Report certified for the construction of the main residence (Board of Supervisor Resolution Nos. 23-237 and 25-132, the project site is located at the base of the “Signal Hill Dune”, which is a remnant of a historically extensive Asilomar Dune complex. The definition of ESHA provided in the Del Monte Forest LUP includes “coastal sand dunes” (refer to Section 4.2.2.3). As such, all areas of the parcel that have not been previously developed by the residence, driveway, walkways, or concrete patio are considered ESHA or to be within 100 feet of ESHA, and therefore subject to protections provided in the LUP.
The updated ADU design is sited primarily within the prior driveway, thereby minimizing disturbance to soils. However, the proposed project is still located within 100 feet of EHSA and requires the granting of a Coastal Development Permit.
Policy 8 of the DMF LUP requires that environmentally sensitive habitat areas be protected against any significant disruption of habitat values. As delineated on the project plans, the footprint for the proposed ADU is contained primarily within the footprint of the prior driveway and extends approximately 112 square feet beyond already hardscaped areas. The portions requiring grading extending beyond the driveway footprint are outside both the CSE and the Dune Habitat Restoration Areas, but within the areas analyzed for development under the prior Final EIR for the main residence. Through adoption of Board of Supervisors Resolutions No. 23-237 and 25-334 (HCD-Planning File Nos. PLN100338 and PLN240077), the areas on the property containing ESHA will have enhanced habitat values with implementation of the Restoration Plan.
Within and around ESHA, Policy 14 requires that areas, native vegetation removal and land disturbance (grading, excavation, paving, etc.) shall be restricted to the minimum amount necessary to accommodate reasonable development. As described above, the proposed project minimizes native vegetation removal and land disturbance to 112 square feet. The revised project design (relocating the ADU to primarily within previously disturbed areas) is supported by Policy 14, Policy 78 (development on slopes), and Policy 33 (tree removal).
ADU
California State law strongly encourages the development of ADUs. Discretionary limitations generally apply only to those 800 square feet or less. However, in the Coastal Zone, local governments must implement ADU regulations that are consistent with both the Coastal Act and State ADU law (Government Code Section 65852.2 (l)). Accordingly, the Appellants’ contention that the Coastal Act supersedes State ADU law lacks merit.
The ADU complies with all required regulations and standards of Section 20.64.030. The Applicant has indicated that Pebble Beach Company has adequate water to serve the proposed project, subject to separate allocation. Carmel Area Wastewater District will provide sewage service to the parcel.
Consistency with previous BOS decision
Appellants assert that the proposed project is not consistent with the previous BOS as it relates to the development of the residence. The Board of Supervisors’ previous decision considered only the development of the single-family dwelling and an attached two-car garage. It neither considered nor precluded future development of accessory structures, such as an ADU or guesthouse, much less their potential location. That Board’s Resolution did not address whether a proposed ADU would meet the County Code’s requirements and thus did not preclude, nor contemplate the construction of an ADU.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Appellants argue that the project cannot be categorically exempt from CEQA because of the structure’s size, implying but not clearly stating that the Chief of Planning’s CEQA action did not “address the potential impacts of the project as a whole” and should not have relied on a 15-year-old biological report. The Appellants therefore conclude that, “[a]ny environmental assessment which does not address the potential impacts of the project as a whole, as required by CEQA, is inadequate.”
Appellants provide no authority for these propositions, which, as written, are difficult to parse. The referenced biological report was used to determine biological impacts in the Certified Final Environmental Impact Report (Board of Supervisor Resolution Nos. 23-237). The environmental impact conclusions of that environmental document are still stable. No evidence has been presented, indicating otherwise. Further, the Chief of Planning found that the project qualified for a Class 3 CEQA Categorical Exemption under CEQA Guidelines section 15303 for new construction or conversion of small structures and that no exceptions applied to render this Exemption inapplicable to the project. By definition, a CEQA exemption means a project is not subject to further environmental review; no preparation of an “environmental assessment” is required. If there was an issue with the Chief of Planning’s CEQA decision, Appellants failed to identify that issue with sufficient specificity to make a meaningful response possible. Moreover, Appellants failed to support these legal arguments with legal authority, effectively waiving them. Appellants’ references to the prior Board CEQA determination are irrelevant; that determination neither considered nor examined the present project.
Here, California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines section 15303 categorically exempts new construction, inclusive of single-family dwellings and accessory structures. As proposed, the project includes construction of a structurally attached 774 square foot Accessory Dwelling Unit. The project does not trigger the exceptions to a categorical exemption under CEQA Guidelines Section 15300.2. The project will not significantly impact scenic resources (including scenic trees), historical resources, or cultural resources. Although the site is within a public viewshed corridor and near known archaeological resources, the ADU's earth-tone finishes, flat roof, project siting, and Condition No. 3 will minimize potential impacts. The project is outside the CSE boundary and dune habitat restoration area, and no substantial evidence indicates a significant environmental or cumulative impact. Therefore, none of the exceptions under Section 15300.2 preclude the Class 3 exemption.
OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT:
The following agencies have reviewed the project, have comments, and/or have recommended conditions:
Environmental Health Bureau
HCD-Engineering Services
HCD-Environmental Services
Pebble Beach Community Services District
The Office of County Counsel
LUAC:
County staff referred the project to the Del Monte Forest Land Use Advisory Committee (LUAC) for review. The LUAC reviewed the project at a duly-noticed public meeting on May 7, 2026. The LUAC voted 5 to 0 in support of the project, with two members abstaining (Attachment E). The LUAC raised concerns about the design and massing of the exterior being too “blocky” due to the contiguous stucco, and wondered whether the Board of Supervisors’ decision to limit the single-family dwelling to the footprint of the original residence applied to the construction of an accessory structure, such as an ADU. The applicant, in response to the design concerns, incorporated an additional window on the backside of the ADU to make it more visually cohesive with the main residence and the surrounding area.
FINANCING:
Funding for staff time associated with this project is included in the FY2026-27 Adopted Budget for HCD Community Development, General Fund 1001-310002.
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS STRATEGIC PLAN GOALS:
The project aligns with Board of Supervisors Strategic Plan Goal A: This action represents effective and timely response to our HCD customers. Processing this application in accordance with all applicable policies and regulations also provides the County accountability for proper management of our land resources.
Mark a check to the related Board of Supervisors Strategic Plan Goals:
__X_Well-Being and Quality of Life
____ Sustainable Infrastructure for the Present and Future
____ Safe and Resilient Communities
____Diverse and Thriving Economy
Link to the Strategic Plan:
<https://www.countyofmonterey.gov/home/showdocument?id=139569>
Prepared by: McKenna Bowling, Associate Planner (831) 755-5298
& Fionna Jensen, Principal Planner (831) 796-6407
Reviewed by: Melanie Beretti, Chief of Planning, AICP
Approved by: Craig Spencer, Director of Housing and Community Development
The following attachments are on file with the HCD:
Attachment A - Draft Resolution
• Draft Conditions, Site Plan, Elevations & Floor Plans
• Colors and Materials
Attachment B - Notice of Appeal
Attachment C - Chief of Planning Resolution No. 26-061
Attachment D - Arborist Report
Attachment E - LUAC Minutes dated May 7, 2026
Attachment F - Public Comment
Attachment G - Vicinity Map
cc: Front Counter Copy; Del Monte Forest LUAC; Pebble Beach Community Services District; HCD-Environmental Services; HCD-Engineering Services; Environmental Health Bureau; McKenna Bowling, Associate Planner; Fionna Jensen, Principal Planner; Melanie Beretti, Chief of Planning; Signal Hill LLC, Property Owner; Massy Mehdipour, Agent; Sam and Betsy Reeves & the Law Offices of Tony Lobardo, Appellants; The Open Monterey Project; LandWatch (Executive Director); Lozeau Drury LLP; Christina McGinnis, Keep Big Sur Wild; Anthony Lombardo and Associates, Interested Party; Planning File PLN250292.