Title
PLN180305-AMD1 - GUNN LEZLIE
Public hearing to consider an Amendment to a previously approved Combined Development Permit (PLN180305) to include the addition of 114 square feet to an attached two-car garage, a new spa, a revised layout of the master bathroom, a revised roof slope from 4.5:12 to 4:12 creating a larger flat roof section, and removal of three (3) additional Monterey Pine trees adding to the thirteen (13) trees previously permitted for removal, for a new total of sixteen (16) trees removed.
Project Location: 4127 Crest Road, Pebble Beach in the Huckleberry Hill planning area of the Del monte Forest Land Use Plan
Proposed CEQA action: Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15303 of the CEQA Guidelines
Report
RECOMMENDATIONS
It is recommended that the Monterey County Planning Commission adopt a resolution to:
1. Find that the project, as a modification to an approved single-family home, qualifies as a Class 3 Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15303 of the CEQA Guidelines, and there are no exceptions pursuant to Section 15300.2; and
2. Approve an Amendment to a previously approved Combined Development Permit (PLN180305) to include the addition of 114 square feet to an attached two-car garage, a new spa, a revised layout of the master bathroom, a revised roof slope from 4.5:12 to 4:12 creating a larger flat roof section, and removal of three (3) additional Monterey Pine trees for a new total of sixteen (16) trees removed, subject to five (5), conditions of approval.
The attached draft resolution includes findings and evidence for consideration (Exhibit A). Staff recommends approval subject to 5 conditions of approval.
PROJECT INFORMATION
Owner: Lezlie Gunn
APN: 008-061-008-000
Zoning: Medium Density Residential, with a maximum gross density of 4 acres per unit and a Design Control Overlay (Coastal Zone) [MDR/4-D (CZ)]
Parcel Size: 0.26 acres (11,314 square feet)
Plan Area: Del Monte Forest Land Use Plan
Flagged and Staked: No
SUMMARY
The project is located along Crest Road, between Sunset Lane and Chamisal Way in the Del Monte Forest. Highway 68 runs behind the subject property. The proposed project is an amendment to an approved land use entitlement for the construction of a single-family home and removal of 13 trees. The subject amendment proposes minor changes to the design of the home, including a change in roof profile, additional space for the attached garage, and a detached spa in the rear yard. The amendment also includes a request to remove (3) three additional Monterey Pine Trees, bringing the tree removal total to (16). The trees proposed for removal are considered “landmark trees” due to their size (33, 39, and 42 inches in diameter).
A supplemental Forest Management Plan (FMP) was prepared detailing the reasoning for the request of additional tree removal. Staff has reviewed the proposal and discussed the tree removal with the Forester. The FMP indicates that one of the trees is already in decline, and that the other two are in fair physiological health but have structural defects and are expected to decline due to the impact of onsite construction operations. The trees were not originally proposed for removal at the time the Planning Commission considered the Coastal Development Permit for the single-family dwelling because they are/were located in the front yard, outside of the footprint of the proposed home. After three years (when the initial Forest management plan was prepared for the site), the natural declining health of these trees has become more apparent, and it is now anticipated that these trees will pose a hazard to the house in the near future given disturbance near the roots and their advancing age. Proposed revisions contemplated in this permit do not directly require removal of the additional trees.
DISCUSSION:
Original Approval and Amendment:
The original approval consisted of a Combined Development Permit to allow the construction of 7,724 square foot single-family dwelling, and the removal of twelve (12) Monterey Pine and (1) Coast Live Oak trees. The subject amendment proposes to remove an additional three (3) Monterey Pine trees, as well as add 114 square feet to the attached 2-car garage, add a new pre-manufactured spa, revise the layout of the master bathroom, revise the roof slope to create a flatter roof section. The additions and revisions do not directly result in the need to remove the trees. Trees are proposed for removal due to health and hazard concerns.
Land Use and Development Standards:
The property is located in an area zoned for medium density residential (MDR) use. The proposed land use is a single-family dwelling. Pursuant to the requirements of the MDR zoning, the first single-family dwelling on a legal lot of record is a principally allowed use within the MDR zone, subject to the securing of a Coastal Administrative Permit.
The proposed project conforms to the site development standards of the base zoning. The added garage does not change the setbacks approved in the original permit. The height of the structure will be increased by an inch, to 26 feet 11 inches, which is within the 27 foot allowable height limit.
Design Review:
The original approval of the single-family home was a Mediterranean style, with the exterior walls being cream and light brown smooth coat stucco and the roofing being a simulated wood shingle roof. Additional finish materials include copper fascia gutters, painted galvanized metal for the railing, and green “bay leaf” metal clad doors and windows. No change in exterior finishes is proposed. The change in roof pitch does not substantially alter the character of the home. The massing of the structure is in line with the surrounding neighborhood. The addition to the garage is a small increase in massing but does not materially alter the character of the façade or the massing of the home.
Tree Removal:
The three (3) trees being proposed for removal are landmark trees, therefore, pursuant to the Del Monte Forest Coastal Implementation Plan, a Coastal Development Permit is required for their removal. On February 27, 2019, the Planning Commission approved a Combined Development Permit allowing construction of a new 3,146 square foot single family dwelling with a 578 square foot attached garage, and removal of 13 trees (12 pine trees and 1 oak tree). This amendment involves removal of three additional trees. As the Planning Commission did not consider this request for tree removal in their original decision on PLN180305, this request is being returned to the Planning Commission in the form of an amendment, along with the additional design changes to the home that the applicant is proposing.
Pursuant to the requirements of the Del Monte Forest Land Use Plan, a supplemental forest management plan was prepared with the foresters reasoning on why the removal is warranted, recommendations for additional tree replanting, and discussion indicating that the additional removal would have a minimal ecological impact. The report is dated April 29, 2021 and is available in HCD-Planning Library File #LIB180295. A site visit was conducted by the project planner on July 1, 2021. A letter from the forester dated July 8, 2021 details the discussion of the meeting at the site and that letter is also available in HCD-Planning Library File #LIB180295. The primary reason for the request to remove the 3 additional trees is due to anticipated root system impacts arising from construction activities which were not previously considered in the original approval. Grading, staging, and construction activity would have an unavoidable impact on the fibrous root system of the trees, which will degrade their health. Additionally, given the presently poor structure of the trees, they represent a hazard to construction operations. This will be compounded by the anticipated impacts due to construction operations, and once the home is completed, would represent a potential hazard to the home.
One of the trees, the 33 inch pine tree (tree #14 in the FMP), is in active decline, with symptoms of a dying tree, including a thinning crown and significant canopy dieback. The other two trees, a 42 inch pine tree (tree #15) and 39 inch pine tree (tree #16), are presently in fair health, but are approaching the end of their lifespan and have structural defects. Both trees have poor balance, tree #15 has a visible decay feature, and tree #16 has the majority of its canopy weight leaning to one side. In discussion with the project forester, he indicated that while presently in fair physiological health, these trees are also expected to be impacted due to construction operations. Older trees such as these are less able to withstand the root system impacts and stressors such as changes in soil condition and compaction that arise from construction operations. In discussing the project, the forester did not believe that changes to the design of the site or the incorporation of traditional measures such as protective fencing or bridging of roots would be adequate to prevent the decline of the trees.
To offset the additional removals, the number of replacement trees recommended is increasing from 18 trees to 24 trees, a 1:1 ratio from all trees less that 24” in diameter and a 2:1 ratio for all trees greater than 24” in diameter. To ensure the long term integrity of the forest resource, staff is recommending the inclusion of a language in the tree replanting condition that the forester review the locations of replanting in an onsite visit prior to planting.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
The project is categorically exempt from CEQA review pursuant to Section 15303, Class 3, for new construction of small structures, including the construction of one single-family residence in a residential zone. The project consists of an amendment to an approved entitlement for the development of a single-family residence, and none of the exceptions detailed in Section 15300.2 apply. Tree removal is addressed in the Forest Management Plan prepared for the project, and the project is not otherwise located near sensitive biological resources. The project is surrounded on all sides by residential development and/or roadways. Views from Highway 68 (a scenic highway) are protected and development will be screened with trees remaining and being planted after construction. There is no potentially significant cumulative affects resulting from the approval of the project, the project does not have any unusual circumstances that would cause a significant environmental effect, and the project does not involve a hazardous waste site.
LUAC
County staff referred the project to the Del Monte Forest Land Use Advisory Committee (LUAC) for review. The LUAC reviewed the project at a duly-noticed public meeting on June 23, 2021, at which all persons had the opportunity to be heard. At the conclusion of the hearing, the LUAC voted 5 - 0, with 3 members absent, to support the project as proposed.
Prepared by: Phil Angelo, Assistant Planner, Ext. 5731
Reviewed by: Craig Spencer, HCD Planning Services Manager
Approved by: Erik Lundquist, AICP, Director of HCD
The following attachments are on file with the HCD:
Exhibit A - Draft Resolution, including:
• Recommended Conditions of Approval
• Site Plan, Floor Plans, Elevations, Color/Material Finishes
Exhibit B - Del Monte Forest LUAC Minutes
Exhibit C - Vicinity Map
Exhibit D - Forest Management Plan with Supplemental Report (LIB180295)
Exhibit E - Planning Commission Resolution 19-005 (PLN180305)
cc: Front Counter Copy; HCD-Environmental Services; Environmental Health Bureau; Anna V. Quenga, Planning Services Manager; Craig Spencer, Planning Services Manager; Lezlie Gunn, Property Owner; Amy Denney, International Design Group, Agent; The Open Monterey Project (Molly Erickson); LandWatch (Executive Director); Project File PLN180305-AMD1