Legislation Details

File #: PC 22-028    Name: PLN210093 MBARI
Type: Planning Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 4/1/2022 In control: County of Monterey Planning Commission
On agenda: 4/13/2022 Final action:
Title: PLN210093 - MONTEREY BAY AQUARIUM RESEARCH INSTITUTE (MBARI) Demolition of an approximately 20,000 square foot restaurant and marine research building and construction of a new two-story, approximately 33,000 square foot, marine research facility building. This permit includes a request for a reduction in parking standards, and development in proximity to environmentally sensitive habitat (Coastal Dune). Project Location: 7600 Sandholdt Road, Moss Landing (Assessor's Parcel Number 133-232-001-000), North County Land Use Plan, Coastal Zone Proposed CEQA Action: Mitigated Negative Declaration
Attachments: 1. Staff Report.pdf, 2. Exhibit A - Discussion.pdf, 3. Exhibit B - Draft Resolution.pdf, 4. Exhibit C - Vicnity Map.pdf, 5. Exhibit D - North County LUAC Minutes (June 16,2021).pdf, 6. Exhibit E - Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration .pdf, 7. Exhibit F - Coastal Hazards and Sea Level Rise Risk Assessment LIB210102.pdf, 8. Exhibit G - Comprehensive Parking Study LIB210103.pdf, 9. Exhibit H - DRAFT MBARI General Development Plan PLN080006.pdf, 10. Exhibit I - Coastal Commission Comment Letter dated March 10, 2022.pdf, 11. Exhibit J - MBARI response to comment letter dated March 17, 2022.pdf

Title

PLN210093 - MONTEREY BAY AQUARIUM RESEARCH INSTITUTE (MBARI)

Demolition of an approximately 20,000 square foot restaurant and marine research building and construction of a new two-story, approximately 33,000 square foot, marine research facility building. This permit includes a request for a reduction in parking standards, and development in proximity to environmentally sensitive habitat (Coastal Dune).

Project Location:  7600 Sandholdt Road, Moss Landing (Assessor's Parcel Number 133-232-001-000), North County Land Use Plan, Coastal Zone

Proposed CEQA Action:  Mitigated Negative Declaration

Report

RECOMMENDATION:

It is recommended that the Planning Commission:

1)                     Adopt a Mitigated Negative Declaration pursuant to Section 15074 of the CEQA Guidelines;

2)                     Approve a Combined Development Permit consisting of:

a.                     a Coastal Development Permit to allow the demolition of an existing 20,609 square foot restaurant and marine research facility building and the construction of a two-story 32,900 square foot marine research facility;

b.                     a Coastal Development Permit for development within 100 feet of environmentally sensitive habitat, (coastal dune); and

c.                     a Coastal Development Permit for a modification in parking standards, by allowing a 10 space reduction in the total required parking for Building G and allowing parking to be considered across the entire MBARI Campus; and

3)                     Adopt a Condition Compliance and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan.

 

Staff has prepared a draft resolution, including findings and evidence, for consideration (Exhibit B). Staff recommends approval of the lot line adjustment subject to 32 conditions of approval.

 

PROJECT INFORMATION:

Applicant: Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute

APN:  133-232-001-000

Zoning:  Light Industrial in the Coastal Zone LI (CZ)

Parcel Size:  0.88 acres (38,109 square feet)

Plan Area:  North County Land Use Plan, Coastal Zone

Flagged and Staked:  Yes

 

 

 

 

SUMMARY:

The Monterey Bay Aquarium Institute (MBARI) is proposing to demolish an existing 20,609 square foot structure and construct a new 32,900 square foot marine research facility in substantially the same footprint. The existing structure has two uses; 13,959 square feet used for a restaurant “Phil’s Fish Market and Eatery”, and the remaining 6,650 square feet used for marine research operations, including an engineering lab and offices. The new structure would be “Building G” of the MBARI campus, located on Moss Landing Island.

 

Staff has provided a detailed discussion (Exhibit A) which identifies issues relative to visual resources & community character, environmentally sensitive habitat area, hazards, parking, and public access, and how they were resolved.

 

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW:

Pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21083 and CEQA Guidelines Sections 15063(a) and 15063(b)(2), Monterey County as Lead Agency completed environmental review to determine if the project may have a significant effect on the environment.  The County prepared a draft Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND) for this project (Exhibit E). The MND was filed with the County Clerk on February 11, 2022, and circulated for public review and comment from February 11, 2022 to March 14, 2022. (SCH No. 2022020267)

 

The draft initial Study and MND identified potentially significant impacts to Biological Resources, Hazards & Hazardous Materials, and Hydrology & Water Quality. Staff has proposed mitigation measures to reduce the identified impacts to a less than significant level. Mitigation Measure No. 1 through 3 would reduce impacts to both Biological Resources and Land Use/Planning  to a less than significant level by: requiring a pre-construction nesting bird survey if construction is scheduled to begin in the bird nesting season to ensure commencement of construction activities will not harm Western Snowy Plovers or other nesting birds; requiring that the existing dune habitat area be protected through construction with exclusionary fencing; and restoring the onsite dune habitat in accordance with a restoration plan prior to occupancy. Mitigation Measure No. 4 would reduce impacts to both Hazards & Hazardous Materials and Hydrology & Water Quality by requiring the applicant set the finish floor elevation one foot above the expected base flood elevation the 10.64 feet above the projected sea level in the year 2060 based on currently available data on sea level rise. This will reduce potential flooding and inundation impacts to a less than significant level.

 

All other standard topics of environmental analysis were found less than significant or no impact. Clarifications and Amplifications to the Initial Study were made in order to address the square footage of the existing structure, which was described as 16,740 square feet (the footprint of the structure) but the floor area is 20,609 square feet which includes multiple stories in the existing marine research facility.

 

Comments on the Initial Study during the circulation period were received from California Coastal Commission (CCC) staff and the Environmental Health Bureau. The Environmental Health Bureau Drinking Water Protection Services - Water Systems team commented indicating that a cross control connection survey and removal of any cross connections would be warranted based on the size of the commercial building and its use. County staff have incorporated a condition requiring a cross connection control survey and removal of any identified cross connections as Condition No. 24. Comments from CCC staff discussed Land Use Plan and Coastal Act consistency generally. Coastal Commission staff identified that while no coastal armoring is indicated as required for the life of the structure based on the analyses provided, there is no statement specifying armoring will not be allowed in the future. CCC staff proposed incorporating a condition similar to Special Condition No. 6 of the Expedition Stage Building (A-3-MCO-17-0068), which prohibits any future armoring of the property, and establishes retreat/re-location procedures in the event that coastal hazards (such as sea level rise) should ever threaten the development. This has been addressed in this project through the incorporation of Condition No. 17, which requires that the applicant record a deed restriction prohibiting any future armoring of the property, with the same retreat/re-location procedures. CCC staff also indicated that maximization of public access and recreational opportunities should be considered key project objectives, and recommends that the project proposal include accessway enhancements in order to maintain consistency with the Coastal Act and Moss Landing Community Plan Policies 5.4.3.6 and 5.4.3.11. After the circulation period, Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute provided a direct response to the Coastal Commissions comments, which indicated they would accept the proposed armoring condition, provided a supplemental analysis from the project geologist indicating that extending the expected operational life of the building to 2080 (60 years) would not significantly impact the shore-wave run-up analysis conducted in the geological report, and indicated they would accept a condition requiring a public signage access plan.

 

County staff reviewed the comments received based on the specific circumstances of this project and determined that they do not alter the conclusions in the draft Initial Study, and no revisions to the draft Initial Study are necessary in response to the comments.  The detailed County responses to the CEQA comments are attached in the draft resolution (Exhibit B).

 

OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT:

The following County agencies or departments reviewed this project:

HCD-Engineering Services (representing Public Works)

North County FPD

Environmental Health Bureau

HCD-Environmental Services

 

LUAC REVIEW:

The project was referred to the North County Land Use Advisory Committee (LUAC) and considered at a public meeting on June 17, 2021. The LUAC expressed concern with the adequacy of on-site parking and with instability due to geotechnical hazards such as liquefaction. At the meeting, representatives of the applicant responded indicating that on-site parking would be provided for all MBARI’s 220 employees, and the LUAC recommended approval of the project as proposed (Exhibit D) 5 - 0 with 3 members absent.

 

Prepared by:                     Phil Angelo, Associate Planner, ext. 5731                                                                                                         

Reviewed by:                     Craig Spencer, HCD Chief of Planning

Approved by:                      Erik Lundquist, HCD Director

 

 

The following attachments are on file with the HCD:

Exhibit A - Discussion

Exhibit B - Draft Resolution, including:

•                     Condition of Approval & Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan

•                     Project Plans

•                     Color Accent Study

Exhibit C - Vicinity Map

Exhibit D - North County LUAC Minutes (June 16, 2021)

Exhibit E - Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration

Exhibit F - Coastal Hazards and Sea Level Rise Risk Assessment (LIB210102)

Exhibit G - Comprehensive Parking Study (LIB210103)

Exhibit H - DRAFT MBARI General Development Plan (PLN080006)

Exhibit I - California Coastal Commission Comment Letter dated March 10, 2022

Exhibit J - MBARI response to comment letter dated March 17, 2022

 

cc: Front Counter Copy; Phil Angelo, Associate Planner; Anna Quenga, AICP, Principal Planner; Craig Spencer, Chief of Planning; Dale Ellis, Agent; Keith Raybould, Applicant; Basilio Martinez, Applicant; California Coastal Commission, Santa Cruz Office; The Open Monterey Project (Molly Erickson); LandWatch; Project File PLN210093