Legislation Details

File #: PC 21-055    Name: PLN040103 EXT 1 - HANSEN JAMES AND PLISKA ALAN T (COUNTRY LAKE ESTATES)
Type: Planning Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 7/22/2021 In control: County of Monterey Planning Commission
On agenda: 7/28/2021 Final action:
Title: PLN040103 EXT 1 - HANSEN JAMES AND PLISKA ALAN T (COUNTRY LAKE ESTATES) Public hearing to consider a six-year extension to a previously approved Vesting Tentative Map (PLN040103) and a request to waive the permit application fees of $6,790 associated with the extension request. Project Location: 70850 and 70970 New Pleyto Road, Bradley CEQA Action: A Mitigated Negative Declaration (adopted June 23, 2006) was prepared for the original subdivision approval (PLN040103). Subsequent review is not required for this extension pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162. The decision on the fees is not a "project" under CEQA.
Attachments: 1. Staff Report, 2. Exhibit A – Draft Resolution, 3. Exhibit B – Authorization Letter from Mr. Alan Pliska, 4. Exhibit C – Board adopted fee waiver policy

Title

PLN040103 EXT 1 - HANSEN JAMES AND PLISKA ALAN T (COUNTRY LAKE ESTATES)

Public hearing to consider a six-year extension to a previously approved Vesting Tentative Map (PLN040103) and a request to waive the permit application fees of $6,790 associated with the extension request.

Project Location: 70850 and 70970 New Pleyto Road, Bradley

CEQA Action: A Mitigated Negative Declaration (adopted June 23, 2006) was prepared for the original subdivision approval (PLN040103). Subsequent review is not required for this extension pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162. The decision on the fees is not a “project” under CEQA.

Report

RECOMMENDATIONS

Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny the request from the applicant to waive the permit application fees of $6,790 associated with processing the tentative map extension and to continue the hearing on consideration of the extension to the August 11, 2021 hearing to give time for the applicant to pay the fee.

 

PROJECT INFORMATION

Property Owner: James E Hansen Family Trust and Alan Pliska (Country Lake Estates)

APN: 423-251-034-000 and 423-071-059-000

Zoning: LDR/1 (Low Density Residential 1 acre per unit)

Plan Area: South County Area Plan

 

SUMMARY

This item includes consideration of a request to waive permit application fees only and the subdivision map extension would be considered at a future date after resolution of the fee issue. On August 19, 2021, Mr. Hansen requested an extension to the approved Vesting Tentative Maps for the Country Lake Estates subdivision off New Pleyto Road in Bradley. The extension request also included the request to waive the permit application fees because, according to the letter, County staff delayed provision of necessary documents required for recordation to satisfy conditions of the tentative map approval and that delay provided inadequate time for the applicants to satisfy conditions and record the necessary final maps. Staff has considered the request for a fee waiver and recommends that the fee be paid in this case for reasons described below.

 

Fee Policy: Pursuant to the Board adopted fee policy, permit fees must be paid in advance of the Planning Commission decision and such fees would be subject to a refund if approved by the Planning Commission. Alternatively, the request for a fee waiver may be considered by the Planning Commission in advance of a decision on the permit extension. If a waiver is approved by the Planning Commission, no fee would be collected, and staff would return to the Planning Commission for a decision on the extension. If the fee waiver is denied, the applicant will be required to pay the fee before a decision on the extension is made. 

 

Planning Commission Hearings: This extension request was initially brought to the Planning Commission on April 28, 2021. At that meeting, it became apparent that staff did not have a complete grasp of the history of this permit and the scope of the extension and fee waiver request. For this reason, the Planning Commission continued the matter to May 12, 2021. At the May 12, 2021 hearing, the matter was continued to June 9, 2021 at the request of staff because, at that time, staff was still coordinating with the applicant on needed application information including the need for concurrence with another affected property owner Mr. Alan Pliska, and the need to collect the permit fees. At the June 9, 2021 hearing, the applicant requested the item to be continued to July 28, 2021. Since the May 12, 2021 hearing, staff has researched permit history and communicated in multiple letters with the applicants. On June 1 and June 29, 2021, Mr. Alan Pliska provided written confirmation of his permission to extend the portion of the tentative map that is the Phase 2 of the Country Lake Estates subdivision approved vesting tentative map (70970 New Pleyto Road; APN: 423-071-059-000).

 

Project history:  The Country Lake Estates subdivision was approved in two parts with two separate Vesting Tentative Maps. On April 11, 2007, the Planning Commission approved Phase 1 of the Subdivision (Resolution No. 07-016) which included:

-                     A Vesting Tentative Map to divide two properties totaling 92 acres into 45 market-rate single family parcels ranging in size from 1.0 acre to 5.1 acres, and five commercial parcels lots adjacent to New Pleyto Road;

-                     A Use Permit for a mutual water system;

-                     A Use Permit for ongoing automobile and recreational vehicle storage on all commercial lots;

-                     A General Development Plan.

 

Phase 2 of the subdivision required approval of a General Plan amendment and Zoning amendment to change the land use and zoning designation on 40 acres of the property from Rural Density Residential to Low Density Residential and included a Vesting Tentative Map to resubdivide 3 lots created in Phase 1 of the subdivision to 10 lots resulting in a total of 52 lots (45 lot in Phase 1 minus 3 lots merged and resubdivided into 10 lots). On December 4, 2007, the Board of Supervisors Amended the General Plan, adopted a Zoning Ordinance and approved the Vesting Tentative Map (Resolution #s 07-405 and 07-406 and Ordinance No. 5094).

 

A Final Map for was submitted by Mr. Hansen on November 6, 2016, for the creation of 14 lots which was a smaller and previously undefined component of the Phase 1 tentative map approval. The Board of Supervisors approved that final map on September 19, 2017 (Resolution No. 17-376).

 

Fee waiver considerations: Application fees are set by the Board of Supervisors and are intended to offset the costs to the County of processing development applications. In this case, the fee for an extension is $6,790. That fee has not been paid in this case.

 

The applicants have requested that the extension fees be waived due to delays associated documents needed for condition compliance. Those documents are a prerequisite to filling a final map for a subdivision. In this case, the Vesting Tentative Maps were both approved in 2007, more than 10 years ago. During the time between the original approvals and the request for an extension, the applicant filed a final map for a previously undefined phase of the subdivision causing the need to identify conditions and improvements for that portion of the subdivision that was not previously contemplated. Monterey County staff invested significant time and resources to work with the applicant to accommodate the 14 lot final map request, and the final map was ultimately approved by the Board in 2017. In addition to the added complexity of the two tentative maps, the two property owners, and the undefined phase of the final map, this project has been subject to multiple automatic extensions provided in the subdivision map act which in total have extended the Map for seven years. An additional two years added after filing of the 14-lot final map.

 

Staff acknowledges that there were delays in processing the required condition compliance documents but given the reasons described above, staff does not believe that those delays warrant waiving the extension fees in this case.

 

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW

Consideration of the fee waiver is not a project as defined in CEQA. A Mitigated Negative Declaration was adopted in approving the Country Lake Estates project (Resolution No. 07-049). An addendum to the adopted Mitigated Negative Declaration has been prepared (Resolution No. 07-406).  The extension does not require subsequent environmental review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15162 because there are no changes to the project and this action is limited to consideration of an extension of the previous approval.

 

OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT

This report on the fee waiver request has been drafted by the Housing and Community Development. Other departments have been involved in review of the subdivision and its multiple iterations including review of this extension and would also be impacted by the decision on the fees.

 

LUAC

The proposed extensions were not referred to the Land Use Advisory Committee (LUAC) because the map extensions did not require referral pursuant to the Board adopted guidelines for review.

 

Prepared by:                      Michelle Huang, Assistant Planner, ext. 5730.

Reviewed by:                     Craig Spencer, Planning Services Manager ext. 5233

Approved by:                     Erik Lundquist, AICP, HCD Director

 

 

The following attachments are on file with HCD:

Exhibit A - Draft Resolution

Exhibit B - Authorization Letter from Mr. Alan Pliska

Exhibit C - Board adopted fee waiver policy

 

 

cc: Front Counter Copy; Erik Lundquist, Chief of HCD-Planning; Craig Spencer, Planning Services Manager; James Hansen, Co-Applicant/Owner; Alan Pliska, Co-applicant/Owner; The Open Monterey Project (Molly Erickson); LandWatch (Executive Director); John H. Farrow; Janet Brennan; Eric Sand; Project File PLN040103 EXT 1