Title
PLN260067 - HU JULIA TR
Public hearing to consider:
a. An appeal by Benjamin Kline of the September 10, 2026, Zoning Administrator’s Resolution approving a Coastal Development permit (PLN260067/Hu) to allow for a Commercial Vacation Rental; and
b. Find that disapproval of the project is Statutorily Exempt pursuant to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines sections 15061(b)(4) and 15270; and
c. A Coastal Development Permit for a Commercial Vacation Rental to allow to allow the use of a residential property for transient lodging for a period of 30 calendar days or fewer.
Body
RECOMMENDATIONS
It is recommended that the Board of Supervisors adopt a resolution to:
1) Grant the appeal by Benjamin Kline of the County of Monterey Zoning Administrator’s Resolution to approve a Coastal Development Permit;
2) Find that disapproval of the project is Statutorily Exempt pursuant to CEQA Guidelines sections 15061(b)(4) and 15270; and; and
3) Deny a Coastal Development Permit for a Commercial Vacation Rental to allow the use of a residential property for transient lodging for a period of 30 calendar days or fewer.
The attached draft resolution includes findings and evidence for consideration (Attachment A).
PROJECT INFORMATION
Applicant: Andrew Ging
Property Owner: Julia Hu TR
APN: 009-303-003-000
Parcel Size: 0.22 AC
Zoning: Medium Density Residential, 2 units per acre with a Design Control Overlay (Coastal Zone) or “MDR/2-D(CZ)”
Plan Area: Carmel Area LUP
Flagged and Staked: N/A
Project Planner: Jack Sorensen Assistant Planner
sorensenj@countyofmonterey.gov; 831-784-5765
SUMMARY:
The project site is located at 26192 Mesa Drive, within the Carmel Area Land Use Plan. The Applicant/Owners, submitted an application seeking to use their existing single-family dwelling located in a residential neighborhood as a Commercial Vacation Rental. The site is developed with an existing 1,464 square foot single-family dwelling consisting of two bathrooms, a kitchen, dining room, family room, living room and detached garage. The Applicant/Owner is proposing that the single-family dwelling be occupied by a maximum of five people overnight and seven people during daytime hours at the property at a time. The property will retain its potable water service through California American Water, and Carmel Wastewater District will also be sufficient in its continuance in providing sewer service for the dwelling. Within the immediate neighborhood, there are seven other commercial vacation rental applications, and two homestays application that are in an applied status and five commercial vacation rentals. Of these five, two have approved discretionary permits and one has been denied. The remaining two are currently in process.
On September 10, 2026, a timely appeal was filed by Benjamin Kline, appealing the County of Monterey Zoning Administrator’s decision to approve the project. These specific contentions are further detailed below and in Attachments A and F. Per Monterey County Code (MCC) section 20.86.070, this hearing is de novo. Staff has prepared a draft resolution to grant the appeal, find the disapproval is statutorily exempt from CEQA, and deny the Coastal Development Permit.
DISCUSSION:
The Appellant, Benjamin Kline, filed an appeal outlining the two contentions (Attachment F), which staff summarizes below:
1. The decision to approve the project was inaccurate due to the information provided regarding the proposed property manager’s qualifications, proximity and information provided to the County.
2. The decision to approve the project did not adequately address the cumulative impact of approving another commercial short-term rental in the neighborhood.
Staff has considered the appeal contentions and provides the following responses:
Response to Contention Nos. 1: Pursuant to Title 7, section 7.120.040.I, the property manager must be available 24 hours per day and must be able to respond to complaints and arrive at the site within 30 minutes. The property manager, which is also the applicant, has provided documentation, certifying that their physical address is at 1595 Plumas Avenue, Seaside, which is a 16-22-minute drive (Attachment E). The decision was based upon this information provided to the County on March 9, 2026. The project was scheduled for hearing and a decision was made to approve the project on September 10, 2026, based on this information and subsequent evidence. (See Finding 1).
Upon receipt of the appeal on September 18, 2026, County staff found that the applicant currently leases this property as a secondary residence and advertises this location as a vacation rental. Information shared on the hosting platform, Air BnB, shows this applicant residing in San Francisco (Attachment H). It was only when the appeal was filed where the applicant clarified this information, stating that they would stay at this location to meet the 30-minute requirement until such a time a local management service company was hired, even though their primary residence is out of the area. Additionally, public testimony taken at the September 10, 2026, hearing and public comment submitted on the application demonstrated the property manager’s inability to return phone calls and complaints of the neighboring property owners within a timely manner. Section 7.120.040.I requires the property manager to be available 24/7 during all times the property is being rented.
Since then, the applicant obtained Bay Homes and Estates in Pacific Grove, located at 719 Lighthouse Avenue, to serve as the designated property manager for this application (Attachment I). Janeen Reavis would be the primary property manager and during non-office hours would reside at 1245 Hilby Avenue, Seaside. Both addresses would meet the 30-minute requirement to arrive on-site. Information provided online shows the address for the Bay Home and Estates to be correct. The applicant stated Ms. Reavis would be residing at an alternative location. It is not clear whether this location is being leased to Ms. Reavis. County records currently indicate a different owner at this address. Nonetheless, this information was only provided upon the receipt of an appeal challenging the original submitted documentation that the decision to approve the project relied on.
Response to Contention Nos. 2: Title 20 section 20.12.050.DD allows for the Commercial Vacation Rental use subject to the granting of a Coastal Development Permit. Commercial Vacation Rentals are an allowed use pursuant to Section 20.64.290, which establishes the regulations for a property operating as a Commercial Vacation Rental. Aside from complying with the required property manager response times, the application currently complies with the other established regulations. Within the immediate neighborhood, there are seven other commercial vacation rental applications, and two homestays application that are in an applied status and five commercial vacation rentals. Of these five, two have approved discretionary permits and one has been denied. The remaining two are currently in process.
The County prepared an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the Vacation Rental Ordinances project, which was certified by the Board of Supervisors on August 27, 2024 (SCH# 2022080643). The EIR analyzed the project for environmental impacts and did not identify any significant impacts of Commercial Vacation Rentals up to the Commercial Vacation Rental cap set for each County of Monterey Planning Area. This Commercial Vacation Rental does not exceed the cap on Commercial Vacation Rentals in the Carmel Area Land Use Plan. The FEIR did address public comments that vacation rentals have the potential for negative side effects including nuisance issues such as traffic, parking and noise. However, no significant environmental effects were identified. County regulations have been developed and are in effect to ensure that vacation rentals remain compatible with existing residential uses. Cumulative impacts of the regulations taken together with other past, present, and probable future projects were analyzed and no significant effects were identified. There is no evidence suggesting that approving this project would result in significant environmental impacts.
CVR Regulations
Based on staff’s review of the planning application materials, the project does not comply with the Chapter 7.120 (Vacation Rental Operation License). The project does comply with the remaining rules and regulations pertaining to zoning uses and other applicable the 1982 County of Monterey General Plan (General Plan), Carmel Area Land Use Plan (CAR LUP), Carmel Area Implementation Plan (CAR CIP), and the Monterey County Coastal Zoning Ordinance (Title 20).
The parcel is zoned Medium Density Residential, 2 units per acre with a Design Control Overlay, or “MDR/2-D(CZ)”. Title 20 Section 20.12.050.DD allows for a residential property to be occupied by a Commercial Vacation Rental, subject to the granting of a Coastal Development Permit. The project complies with all Commercial Vacation Rental requirements pursuant to Section 20.64.290, including: adequate emergency response times for fire and emergency medical, adequate parking, limitations on the number of Commercial Vacation Rentals per legal lot, limitations on the number of Commercial Vacation Rentals an individual can have ownership interest in, and adequate property management information. The property has a maximum occupancy of five overnight guests and seven daytime guests. The proposed occupancy does not exceed the limits set forth in the California Uniform Housing Code and the requirements enumerated in Title 7 Section 7.120.070.C
CEQA:
The denial of project qualifies as exemption from environmental review pursuant to CEQA Guidelines sections 15061(b)(4) and 15270. These exemptions applies to projects that are rejected or disapproved by a public agency which a public agency rejects or disapproves. The Board of Supervisors’ action to deny the project fits within these exemptions. The County is a public agency disapproving the project. Statutory exemptions from CEQA are not qualified by the exceptions applicable to categorical exemptions in CEQA Guidelines section 15300.2.
OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT:
The following agencies have reviewed the project, have comments, and/or have recommended conditions:
Office of County Counsel
FINANCING:
The Board appeal fee is typically $3,572; however, projects in the coastal zone that are appealable to the California Coastal Commission are not charged an appeal fee. Funding for staff time associated with this project is included in the FY 26-27 Adopted Budget for HCD Community Development, Fund 1001, Appropriation HCD101, Department 310002.
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS STRATEGIC PLAN GOALS:
The project aligns with Board of Supervisors Strategic Plan Goals A: This action represents effective and timely response to our HCD customers. Processing this application in accordance with all applicable policies and regulations also keeps the County accountable to the public for proper management of public land resources.
Mark a check to the related Board of Supervisors Strategic Plan Goals:
__X Well-Being and Quality of Life
____ Sustainable Infrastructure for the Present and Future
____ Safe and Resilient Communities
____ Diverse and Thriving Economy
____ Dynamic Organization and Employer of Choice
Link to the Strategic Plan:
< <https://www.countyofmonterey.gov/home/showdocument?id=139569>>
Prepared by: Jack Sorensen, Assistant Planner and Jacquelyn M. Nickerson, Principal Planner
Reviewed by: Melanie Beretti, AICP, Chief of Planning
Approved by: Craig Spencer, HCD Director
The following attachments are on file with Clerk of the Board:
Attachment A - Draft Resolution
Attachment B - Vicinity Map
Attachment C - Home Inspection Checklist
Attachment D - Public Comment
Attachment E - Vacation Rental Operation License Application Materials
Attachment F - Notice of Appeal by Benjamin Kline
Attachment G - County of Monterey Zoning Administrator Resolution No. 26-087
Attachment H - County Research
Attachment I - New Property Manager
cc: Front Counter Copy; HCD-Planning; Jack Sorensen, Assistant Planner; Jacquelyn Nickerson, Principal Planner; Julia Hu, Property Owner; Andrew Ging, Applicant; Benjamin Kline, Appellant; Interested Parties: The Open Monterey Project (Molly Erickson); Laborers International Union of North America (Lozeau Drury LLP); Christina McGinnis, Keep Big Sur Wild; LandWatch; Planning File PLN260067.