Title
PLN160047 - POST RANCH INN & ONE SIMO PARCEL C LLC
Public hearing to consider an amendment to an approved General Development Plan and a Combined Development Permit (PLN970492) allowing the relocation of existing and approved resort and supportive facilities at the Post Ranch Inn, including conversion of existing guest units to spa rooms, conversion of employee housing units to visitor serving units, and construction of new visitor serving units without increasing the number of units overall (40 visitor serving units and 44 employee housing units). Improvements to water and fire suppression supply systems, wastewater treatment systems and stormwater systems are also proposed. The proposed development will require removal of 6 California bay laurel trees and 1 Coast redwood and is located within 100 feet of Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Areas (ESHA) and within 750 feet of a positive archaeological site.
Project Location: The properties are located at 47900 & 47998 Highway 1, Big Sur, Big Sur Coast Land Use Plan
Proposed CEQA Action: Mitigated Negative Declaration
Report
RECOMMENDATIONS
It is recommended that the Planning Commission:
1. Adopt a Mitigated Negative Declaration pursuant to Section 15074 of the CEQA Guidelines;
2. Amend an approved General Development Plan (PLN970492) for “current” and “future” development of the facility to amend the configuration of the resort facility while maintaining the approved buildout of 40 visitor serving units and 44 employee housing units;
3. Approve a Combined Development Permit for the current phase of development consisting of:
a. A Coastal Development Permit and Design Approval to allow relocation 4 guest units (construct 2 previously approved units in a different location, convert the Post House into 1 guest unit, and convert the Post Caretaker Unit into 1 guest unit); relocation of 12 employee housing units (3 two-bedroom housing units, 3 studio housing units, a 3 unit staff bunkhouse, and 3 management housing units);
relocation of spa facilities (convert 4 guest units contained the Butterfly building to a spa treatment room); repurpose the Maintenance Building into an Employee Commons Hall; and consolidation of Central Service Facilities (construct a workshop and 2 staff restrooms);
b. A Coastal Development Permit for improvements to a portions of an existing public trail;
c. A Coastal Development Permit and Design Approval for the construction of 2 ADA accessible restrooms (approximately 95 square feet each) and a 138 square foot addition to the Reception building;
d. A Coastal Development Permit to improve water and fire water supply systems, wastewater treatment system, and stormwater treatment facilities;
e. Coastal Development Permit to allow the removal of 7 protected trees;
f. Coastal Development Permit to allow development within 100 feet of ESHA; and
g. Coastal Development Permit to allow development within 750 feet of a positive archaeological site; and
4. Adopt a Condition Compliance and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan.
The attached draft resolution includes findings and evidence for consideration (Exhibit B). Staff recommends approval of the General Development Plan amendment and construction of the Post Ranch Inn facilities subject to 34 conditions of approval, 18 of which are mitigation measures.
PROJECT INFORMATION
Property Owners: Post Ranch Inn & One Simo Parcel C LLC
Agent: Aengus Jeffers
APNs: 419-311-038-000 and 419-311-042-000
Zoning: Watershed Scenic Conservation, 40 acres per unit, with Design Control and Historic Resources overlay districts, coastal zone (WSC/40-D-HR[CZ]) and Visitor Serving Commercial, with Design Control and Historic Resources overlay districts, coastal zone (VSC-D-HR[CZ])
Existing Parcel Sizes: 101.92 acres
Plan Area: Big Sur Coast Land Use Plan
Flagged and Staked: No
SUMMARY
The subject property contains just under 102 acres and is located in Big Sur, approximately 1 mile south of the intersection of Sycamore Canyon Road and Highway 1, west of the Post House and Ventana Inn. The site contains existing development with visitor serving facilities, known as the Post Ranch Inn (PRI).
PRI has been a recreational resort for over 30 years. On May 31, 1989, the Monterey County Planning Commission certified the Post Ranch Inn FEIR and approved a Coastal Development Permit (File No. PC-6336, Resolution No. 89-176) allowing establishment of the resort. The 1989 approval allowed 30 guest units, a small lodge and restaurant, reception lodge, conference room, pool house, pool and yurt, well and water storage, septic systems, storage supply building, mercantile building, woodshop, woodshed, 20 employee units, and a fire brigade building. The guest units were constructed north of the lodge with 4 different designs; individual ground units, double ground units, multiple ground units, and treehouse units.
On June 25, 2002, the Monterey County Board of Supervisors adopted a Mitigated Negative Declaration and approved a Combined Development Permit and General Development Plan (File No. PLN970492, Resolution No. 02-269) allowing a minor subdivision and lot line adjustment; 10 new inn units; 24 new employee housing units; a yoga, exercise, and spa building; a mercantile and gallery; service building; maintenance shop; wastewater system improvements; grading; landscaping; habitat restoration and protection; relocation of parking areas; increase and improvement of public access trails and recreation areas; demolition of a pool, adjacent structures, and Quonset buildings; relocation of a firewood shed, and a new 150,000 gallon water tank.
Other site improvements consist of an entrance gate, garden/gallery, the Post House and Caretaker Unit, a utility/wine bunker, and wireless communication facilities.
The proposed project includes an amendment to the approved General Development Plan to allow changes to the layout of structures and facilities such as improvements to existing visitor serving units, employee housing units, and internal infrastructure facilities. The project does not include an increase to the total number of visitor serving or employee housing units (40 visitor serving units and 44 employee housing units). Instead, it would allow conversion of 4 existing guest units to spa rooms, conversion of 2 employee housing units to visitor serving units, and construction of new visitor serving units and employee housing units to reach the approved buildout (see Table 1 in Exhibit B). In accordance with Monterey County Code requirements, a General Development Plan (GDP) demonstrates the long range development and operation of facilities, including expansion and new development, operational changes, infrastructure improvements and alternative development opportunities. As such, the proposed GDP amendment includes near-term (Current Phase) and long-term (Future Phase) facility improvements.
The project application includes the required entitlements for the Current Phase development which is described below in 2 categories: “Structure Improvements” and “Infrastructure Improvements”. Overall, the Current Phase facility improvements will require site clearing, grading of approximately 2,150 cubic yards of cut and 900 cubic yards of fill, and the removal 6 California bay laurel trees ranging from 12 inches to 25 inches in diameter, 1 Coast redwood 6 inches in diameter, and 1 stump 36 inches in diameter.
Future Phase improvements identified in the GDP amendment include Construction of a detached spa room and a detached ADA accessible restroom approximately 150-feet southeast of the Sierra Mar restaurant as well as an addition to the Sierra Mar restaurant. However, the applicant does not seek approval of entitlements required for this development at this time. Instead, the GDP acknowledges the need for permit approval and subsequent environmental review, if required.
DISCUSSION
Due to the detail necessary to provide the Commission with sufficient background information, permit history and potential issues/concerns identified through review of the project, staff has provided a more detailed discussion in Exhibit A.
OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT
The following County agencies have reviewed this project, have comments, and/or have recommended conditions:
|
|
HCD-Development Services HCD-Environmental Services |
|
|
Environmental Health Bureau Cal Fire - Coastal on behalf of Carmel Fire Protection Associates |
LUAC
The Big Sur Land Use Advisory Committee (LUAC) reviewed the project at a duly noticed public meeting on June 26, 2018, and voted 4 to 0 to approve the project with consideration of keeping lighting low and down facing, not utilizing black asphalt for new roads and for staff to clarify the zoning of parcels “C” and “D” (Exhibit F). LUAC comments have been addressed as the project has been conditioned to require review and approval of a final exterior lighting plan concurrent with construction permit applications. Non-asphalt roadway materials will be used unless required by fire regulations. The Initial Study prepared for the project clarified and discussed zoning of PRI Parcels C and D. As discussed in Exhibit A of this report, development is associated with improvements and reconfiguration of an existing visitor serving facility which is consistent with the properties land use designations and zoning. Recommended findings for consistency are also contained in Exhibit B.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
An Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration or IS/MND (Exhibit C) was prepared for the project and circulated from March 30, 2021, to April 29, 2021. Comments from State of California Department of Fish and Wildlife were received on April 29, 2021 (Exhibit D). CDFW acknowledges that the “MND indicates there is potentially significant impact unless mitigation measures are taken but the measures listed are general and non-specific and/or may be inadequate to reduce impacts to less than significant.” CDFW listed concern with 2 special-status species; the State endangered foothill yellow-legged frog (Rana boylii) and the federally threatened and State species of special concern California red-legged frog (Rana draytonii).
Staff attempted to meet with CDFW staff but was unsuccessful. The applicant submitted a response prepared by a biologist addressing the comment letter (Exhibit E) which provided substantial evidence indicating that there no known occurrences of the foothill yellow-legged over the last 20 years. Mitigation measures were recommended by CDFW but were not incorporated as they were either redundant with mitigations already identified in the IS/MND or they would provide mitigation where there was no impact. See the discussion contained in Exhibit A for further details.
The applicant has accepted proposed mitigation measures to reduce potential impacts to less than significant. The project as proposed, conditioned, and mitigated, would have less than significant impact on the environment. The mitigation measures are incorporated as project conditions of approval (see Exhibit B, Attachment 1).
Prepared by: Philip Angelo, Assistant Planner, ext. 5731, and
Anna V. Quenga, AICP, Senior Planner, ext. 5175
Reviewed by: Craig Spencer, HCD Planning Services Manager
Approved by: Erik Lundquist, AICP, Director of HCD
The following attachments are on file with HCD:
• Exhibit A - Discussion
• Exhibit B - Draft Resolution, including;
o Attachment 1 - Conditions of Approval and Mitigation Measures
o Attachment 2 - General Development Plan
§ Site Development Plan,
§ Floor Plans,
§ Elevations, and
§ Colors and Materials
o Attachment 3 - Employee Housing Plan
• Exhibit C - Initial Study & Mitigated Negative Declaration
• Exhibit D - Initial Study Public Comment
• Exhibit E - Response Letter to CDFW Initial Study Comments
• Exhibit F - Big Sur LUAC Minutes
• Exhibit G - Vicinity Map
cc: Front Counter Copy; Planning Commission; Carmel Fire Protection Associates; Environmental Health Bureau; HCD-Development; HCD-Environmental Services; Erik Lundquist, AICP, HCD Director; Craig Spencer, HCD Planning Services Manager; Anna Quenga, AICP, Project Planner; Phil Angelo, Assistant Planner; Laura Lawrence c/o Aengus Jeffers, Agent; Post Ranch Inn and One Simo Parcle C, LLC, Owner; Open Monterey Project (Molly Erickson); LandWatch (Executive Director); Planning File PLN160047