Legislation Details

File #: PC 22-029    Name: PLN110173- EXT 1 - SEPTEMBER RANCH (VESTING TENTATIVE MAP EXTENSION)
Type: Planning Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 4/1/2022 In control: County of Monterey Planning Commission
On agenda: 4/13/2022 Final action:
Title: EXTENSION FOR VESTING TENTATIVE MAP EXPIRATION RELATING TO SEPTEMBER RANCH SUBDIVISION PROJECT (PLN110173) Grant an extension to the expiration of the Vesting Tentative Map for the period of two years, to May 9, 2024, pursuant to Government Code section 66452(e). Project Location: approximately 2.5 miles east of Highway 1 on the north side of Carmel Valley Road, between Canada Way & Valley Greens Drive, Mid Carmel Valley area Proposed CEQA action: Consider previously certified Environmental Impact Report for the September Ranch Subdivision Project.
Attachments: 1. Staff Report.pdf, 2. Exhibit A - Draft Resolution.pdf, 3. Exhibit B - Letter from Applicant October 19, 2021.pdf, 4. Exhibit C - September Ranch EIR (hyperlink), 5. Exhibit D - Public comment received prior to distribution of the staff report.pdf

Title

EXTENSION FOR VESTING TENTATIVE MAP EXPIRATION RELATING TO SEPTEMBER RANCH SUBDIVISION PROJECT (PLN110173)

Grant an extension to the expiration of the Vesting Tentative Map for the period of two years, to May 9, 2024, pursuant to Government Code section 66452(e).

Project Location: approximately 2.5 miles east of Highway 1 on the north side of Carmel Valley Road, between Canada Way & Valley Greens Drive, Mid Carmel Valley area

Proposed CEQA action: Consider previously certified Environmental Impact Report for the September Ranch Subdivision Project.

Report

RECOMMENDATIONS:

It is recommended that the Monterey County Planning Commission adopt a resolution to:

a.                     Consider the previously certified Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the September Ranch subdivision; and

b.                     Grant an extension to the expiration of the tentative map for the period of two years, to May 9, 2024, pursuant to Government Code Section 66452.6(e).

The attached draft resolution includes findings and evidence for consideration (Exhibit A). 

 

PROJECT INFORMATION:

Property Owner: September Ranch Partners (Carmel Reserve LLC)

Agent: Cody Phillips

Project Location: ~ 2.5 miles east of Highway 1 on the north side of Carmel Valley Road, between Canada Way & Valley Greens Drive, Mid Carmel Valley area

Zoning: Medium Density Residential 10-D-S-RAZ and Low Density Residential, 2.5 D-S-RAZ

Plan Area: Carmel Valley Master Plan

Flagged and Staked: N/A

 

SUMMARY/DISCUSSION:

The September Ranch Subdivision included:

1) a Vesting Tentative Map (VTM) for the subdivision of 891 acres into seventy-three market-rate residential lots and twenty-two affordable housing lots (fifteen inclusionary and seven deed restricted workforce housing lots) for a total of ninety-five residential lots; a 20.2 acre existing equestrian facility and accessory structures related to that use (Parcel E); 300.5 acres of common open space (Parcels A & C);  242.9 acres of public open space for donation/dedication (Parcel D); 250.7 acres of private open space (conservation and scenic easement) on each lot outside of the building envelope; 6.9 acres of open space reserved for future public facilities (Parcel B); annexation to the Carmel Area Wastewater District for sewage disposal;

2) a Use Permit for the public/commercial use of the equestrian center & stables for a maximum of 50 horses and a maximum water use of 3.0 acre-feet per year;

3) a Use Permit for an on-site water system including new wells, backup well(s), booster pumps, water tanks and piping for fire suppression and residents of the subdivision;

4) a Use Permit for removal of a maximum of 819 protected Coast Live Oak trees;

5) an Administrative Permit for up to 100,000 cubic yards of grading in an "S" (Site Plan Review) Overlay Zoning District for subdivision infrastructure & improvements including, but not limited to development of roads, water tanks, water system & drainage detention areas;

6) a Use Permit to allow development on slopes greater than 30 percent for affordable housing on Lots 5 through 11, subdivision infrastructure & subdivision improvements; and

7) an Administrative Permit for affordable housing, equestrian center caretaker unit/public office, a tract sales office and a security gatehouse.  The property is located approximately 2.5 miles east of Highway 1 on the north side of Carmel Valley Road, between Canada Way & Valley Greens Drive, Mid Carmel Valley area (Assessor's Parcel Numbers in process of being updated by the County Assessor: 015-171-010-000, 015-171-012-000, 015-361-013-000 and 015-361-014-000), Carmel Valley Master Plan.

 

On March 27, 2013, by Resolution Number 13-010, the Planning Commission approved an extension of four (4) years to the Combined Development Permit (PLN110173, original permit number PLN050001). The discretionary extension of PLN110173 was the first and only application of extension to the VTM pursuant to Government Code Section (GCS) 66452.6(e). Automatic extensions had occurred in the lifetime of the VTM, however. The last automatic extension applied to the VTM in 2020 extended the expiration date to May 9, 2022.

 

On October 19, 2021, the agent for the owner requested an extension of PLN110173 for two additional years and projected the expiration date to become May 9, 2022 (Exhibit B). Staff assessed the timeline of events pertaining to the VTM, considered the subdivider’s written request, and considered the Subdivision Map Act and Title 19 (County’s subdivision ordinance). The maximum length of time for which the County is authorized to grant a discretionary time extension under GCS 66452.6(e) is six years.

 

VTM Timeline:

•                     Monterey County Board of Supervisors approved a Combined Development Permit for the September Ranch Subdivision project, which included a VTM, on November 9, 2010 (PC95062, PLN050001)

•                     PC95062 VTM would have expired November 9, 2012, but state legislated automatic twelve months’ extension (GCS 66452.21) set the expiration to November 9, 2013.

•                     Planning Commission heard an extension request by the permit holder on August 10, 2011 and March 27, 2013 and extended the VTM by four years under GCS 66452.6(e) to November 9, 2018 (13-010, PLN110173).

•                     State legislated automatic extensions added twenty-four months (GCS 66452.24) to November 9, 2020.

•                     State legislated automatic extensions added another eighteen months (GCS 65914.5) to May 9, 2022.

•                     The VTM for Phase 2 can be extended by decision makers in response to the permit holder’s request for two more years under GCS 66452.6(e) to May 9, 2024.

 

Staff recommends that the Commission approve the extension of the expiration of the map for the period of two years, to May 9, 2024. Staff also recommends that PLN110173 remain the operative permit for condition compliance.

 

CEQA:

An Environmental Impact Report (EIR) was certified for the September Ranch Subdivision on November 9, 2010 (SCH# 1995083033, Exhibit C). This proposed extension to the approval will not change the project or any of the circumstances under which the project was considered. Staff recommends that the Planning Commission consider the previously certified EIR prior to approving the extension to the expiration date for the project.

 

OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT:

County Counsel has reviewed the report as to form.

 

Prepared by:  Mary Israel, ext. 5183, Senior Planner                     

Reviewed by:                     Craig Spencer, Chief of Planning

Approved by:                     Erik V. Lundquist, AICP, Director of Housing and Community Development

 

The following attachments are on file with the HCD:

Exhibit A - Resolution                      

Exhibit B - Letter from Applicant October 19, 2021

Exhibit C - September Ranch EIR (See attached coversheet for hyperlink)

https://www.co.monterey.ca.us/government/departments-a-h/housing-community-development/planning-services/resources/environmental-documents/archived/final-revised-eir-for-september-ranch

Exhibit D - Public comment received prior to distribution of the staff report

 

cc: Front Counter Copy; County Counsel, Craig Spencer (Chief of Planning); Carmel Reserve LLC (Owner); The Open Monterey Project (Molly Erickson); LandWatch; Engineering Services; Environmental Services; Project File PLN110173