Legislation Details

File #: PC 23-070    Name: PLN220212 - CARMEL ASSISTED LIVING LLC
Type: Planning Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 8/11/2023 In control: County of Monterey Planning Commission
On agenda: 8/30/2023 Final action:
Title: PLN220212 - CARMEL ASSISTED LIVING LLC Public hearing to consider a lot line adjustment between four legal lots of record containing 3.78 acres, resulting in four parcels containing 1.32 acres [Adjusted Parcel A],0.59 acres [Adjusted Parcel B], 1.41 acres [Adjusted Parcel C], and 0.46 acres [Adjusted Parcel D]. Project Location: The properties are located at 24945 Valley Way, Carmel, Carmel Land Use Plan, Coastal Zone. Proposed CEQA Action: Find the project qualifies for a Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15305 of the CEQA Guidelines and no exceptions pursuant to Section 15300.2 can be made.
Attachments: 1. Staff Report, 2. Exhibit A - Draft Resolution, 3. Exhibit B - Supplemental Historical Assessment (LIB230183), 4. Exhibit C - Carmel Unincorporated Highlands LUAC Minutes (June 5, 2023), 5. Exhibit D - Carmel Unincorporated Highlands LUAC Minutes (July 17, 2023), 6. Exhibit E - Public Comment, 7. RESpc_23-032_PLN220212_083023, 8. LET_PC_ PLN220212_083023

Title

PLN220212 - CARMEL ASSISTED LIVING LLC

Public hearing to consider a lot line adjustment between four legal lots of record containing 3.78 acres, resulting in four parcels containing 1.32 acres [Adjusted Parcel A],0.59 acres [Adjusted Parcel B], 1.41 acres [Adjusted Parcel C], and 0.46 acres [Adjusted Parcel D].

Project Location:  The properties are located at 24945 Valley Way, Carmel, Carmel Land Use Plan, Coastal Zone.

Proposed CEQA Action:  Find the project qualifies for a Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15305 of the CEQA Guidelines and no exceptions pursuant to Section 15300.2 can be made.

Report

RECOMMENDATION:

It is recommended that the Planning Commission adopt a resolution:

1.                     Finding that the project is a minor lot line adjustment, which qualifies as a Class 5 Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15305(a) of the CEQA Guidelines, and there are no exceptions pursuant to Section 15300.2; and

2.                     Approving a Coastal Development Permit to allow a Lot Line Adjustment of four legal lots of record: Parcel A (3.18 acres), Parcel B (0.29 acres), Parcel C (0.17 acres) and Parcel D (0.14 acres), resulting in four lots containing 1.32 acres (Adjusted Parcel A), 0.59 acres (Adjusted Parcel B), 1.41 acres (Adjusted Parcel C) and 0.46 acres (Adjusted Parcel D).

Staff has prepared a draft resolution, including findings and evidence, for consideration (Exhibit A).  Staff recommends approval of the lot line adjustment subject to five conditions of approval.

 

PROJECT INFORMATION:

Property Owners: Carmel Assisted Living LLC

Agent:  Anna Bornstein, EMC Planning Group and Adam Jeselnick, Architect

APNs:  009-061-003-000 (Parcel A and D); 009-061-002-000 (Parcel B) and 009-061-005-000 (Parcel C)

Zoning:  Medium Density Residential, 2 units per acre, with a Design Control Overlay (Coastal Zone) [MDR/2-D (CZ)]

Existing Parcel Sizes:  Parcel A (3.18 acres), Parcel B (0.29 acres), Parcel C (0.17 acres) and Parcel D (0.14 acres)

Plan Area:  Carmel Area Land Use Plan, Coastal Zone

Flagged and Staked:  Not required because the proposed lot line adjustment does not involve any structural development.

Project Planner:  Fionna Jensen, Senior Planner

                     (831) 796-6407 or JensenF1@co.monterey.ca.us

 

SUMMARY/DISCUSSION:

The Applicant proposes a lot line adjustment (LLA) between contiguous lots accessed of Highway 1 or Valley Way Road in the unincorporated areas surrounding Carmel-by-the-Sea.  This area of the County consists primarily of residential lots with corresponding residential development. The LLA involves four legal lots totaling 3.78 acres. Existing Parcel A is currently developed with the former Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula, an attached garage, and a detached memory care building. Existing Parcels B and C are currently vacant. Parcel D is also vacant but does contain a paved access easement from Highway 1. As proposed, the lot line adjustment will rearrange the total acreage (3.78 acres) and result in four lots containing 1.32 acres [Adjusted Parcel A], 0.59 acres [Adjusted Parcel B], 1.41 acres [Adjusted Parcel C] and 0.46 acres [Adjusted Parcel D]. As proposed, the resulting lots would remain conforming as to minimum lot size, maximum density, structural coverage, and setbacks. All lots currently have, and would retain, separate and direct access to Valley Way. The Highway 1 access easement is intended only for emergency ingress and egress.

 

The four parcels are zoned MDR/2(CZ), which allows a maximum density of 2 units per acre. The LLA would not create new lots (i.e., would not subdivide of the existing parcels), and would not intensify the combined level of development allowed on the parcels because no parcel will contain over 4 acres. No development is proposed as part of this application.  Per the zoning district, the minimum lot size is 6,000 square feet or 0.14 acres. The resulting parcels will contain 1.32 acres [Adjusted Parcel A], 0.59 acres [Adjusted Parcel B], 1.41 acres [Adjusted Parcel C] and 0.46 acres [Adjusted Parcel D]. The existing development on Parcel A complies with the required site coverage and floor area ratio requirements. As proposed, the former Community Hospital (approximately 22,662 square feet) and attached garage (approximately 2,318 square feet) will be located entirely on Adjusted Parcel A, resulting in a site coverage of approximately 23.2 percent and a floor area ratio of approximately 41.46 percent, which is below the maximum allowed. As proposed, the former Community Hospital and attached garage will continue to maintain the required setbacks on Adjusted Parcel A [36.5 feet (front), 14 feet and 22.5 feet (sides), and 13 feet (rear)]. As proposed, the detached memory care facility (4,431 square feet) will be located on Adjusted Parcel C and will have a front setback of over 100 feet, and side and rear setbacks of approximately 25 feet, thus meeting the maximum allow lot coverage and floor area ratio and minimum setbacks. Adjusted Parcels B and D will remain vacant. The resulting/adjusted parcels meet all MDR/2(CZ) density, setback, site coverage, and floor area ratio requirements.

 

No demolition, construction, or other type of structural development is proposed. There are no identified impacts to environmental resources. At this time, staff only recommends the granting of the Coastal Development Permit to allow the LLA. Future development on the adjusted parcels would be required to conform to the Monterey County Code requirements in effect at the time and obtain all necessary permits.

 

Pursuant to State law, the County’s Draft Housing Element includes an evaluation of existing and projected housing needs, a review of previous goals and programs, an inventory of sites, identification of housing constraints, development of housing programs to address needs, and quantifiable objectives. The Draft Housing Element is required to show that the County has adequate sites available to accommodate its Regional Housing Need Allocation (RHNA), based on statewide and regional estimates determined by State Housing and Community Development. No specific housing or development projects within the County’s jurisdiction are proposed as part of the Draft Housing Element update. Existing Parcel A and D have been identified in the County’s “Preliminary Draft Sites Inventory for the 6th Cycle Housing Element” as adequate available land that is able to partially accommodate the County’s “fair share” RHNA units. Parcels A and B are identified as Site No. 26, with a total unit allocation of 52; with a combined acreage of 3.23, this equates to a density of approximately 16 dwelling units per acre. According to the applicants, the intent of the LLA is to rearrange the lots to better accommodate further development needed. Although no development is proposed in this LLA, the property and existing hospital are intended to be developed for employee, nurse, or other affordable housing. No application for such development has been applied for at this time. If and when the applicant seeks to redevelop the site to accommodate a higher density, the subject property would require the approval and certification of a Local Coastal Program (Carmel Area Land Use Plan and Coastal Implementation Plan) Amendment to allow the property to be rezoned and redesignated to High-Density Residential with a density greater than 2 units. Additionally, the application would be required to submit evidence indicating that there is or will be adequate potable water and sewer service.

 

Historical Resources

The 2015 Phase 1 Historical Assessment (LIB150233) identified the boundary of the historic property as defined by “the original 3.78 acres of the hospital site, currently defined as three legal parcel numbers (APNs: 009-061-002, -003, and -005)” and the adjacent landscape features. The 2015 Assessment also determined the former Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula, attached garage, and surrounding landscape retain historical integrity. However, the Assessment confirmed that the detached memory care facility does not retain any historical integrity. To ensure that the proposed lot line adjustment does not affect the property’s historical character, a supplemental Historical Report (LIB230183; Exhibit B) was prepared. The supplemental report concluded that the interior or shared lot lines between the four parcels are not part of the “historic property boundary.” Thus, the Project Historian determined that the proposed LLA would not in cause a loss of integrity to the historic property or structures. Therefore, the project would not impact any historical resources. The Project Historian noted that any redevelopment of the site would need to be consistent with the Sate of Interior’s Standard for Rehabilitation.

 

OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT:

The following County agencies or departments reviewed this project:

HCD-Engineering Services

HCD-Environmental Services

Environmental Health Bureau

Carmel Highlands Fire Protection District

 

LAND USE ADIVISORY COMMITTEE

On June 5, 2023, the Carmel Unincorporated/Highlands Land Use Advisory Committee (LUAC) reviewed the project. At this meeting, staff and the applicant requested a continuance to July 17, 2023, to allow time to complete the project site’s lot legality determination. The LUAC voted to continue the item to July 17, 2023, and requested that staff schedule site visit (Exhibit C). Staff, the applicant, members of the public, and all LUAC members were present at the site visit on July 17, 2023. Members of the public raised concerns regarding redevelopment of the site. During the regular scheduled LUAC meeting, members of the public requested to know the property owner’s intent of the adjusted four parcels and raised concerns relating to “overdevelopment of the site” and traffic/safety. After public testimony, the LUAC voted 5-1 (5 ayes, 1 nays) to support the project as proposed (Exhibit D). Staff responded to the raised concerns. HCD-Engineering Services forwarded the proposal to the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) for review. Caltrans raised no concerns to retention of the Highway 1 access easement, which the applicant intends on limiting to emergency vehicle ingress and egress. Although no development is proposed in this application, the applicant’s representatives have informed staff that property owner intends to redevelop the former Community Hospital site as housing for medical professionals. Development of the adjusted parcels will require separate environmental review and discretionary review and approval from the County of Monterey.

 

CEQA:

California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15305(a) categorically exempts minor lot line adjustments not resulting in the creation of any new parcel. The applicant proposes a minor lot line adjustment between four legal lots of record consisting of Parcel A (3.18 acres), Parcel B (0.29 acres), Parcel C (0.17 acres) and Parcel D (0.14 acres). After the adjustment, there will be four lots of record containing 1.32 acres [Adjusted Parcel A], 0.59 acres [Adjusted Parcel B], 1.41 acres [Adjusted Parcel C] and 0.46 acres [Adjusted Parcel D]. No new lots will be created by the lot line adjustment. No demolition, construction, or other type of development is proposed under this entitlement. The lot line adjustment will not intensify the level of development allowed on the parcels. Any future permitting of an additional development on these four lots is currently limited until proper potable water credits and discretionary permits are obtained.

 

Prepared by:    Fionna Jensen, Senior Planner x6407

Reviewed by:  Anna Ginette Quenga, AICP, Principal Planner

Approved by:  Craig Spencer, HCD Chief of Planning

 

The following attachments are on file with HCD:

Exhibit A - Draft Resolution

•                     Recommended Conditions of Approval

•                     Lot Line Adjustment Plan

Exhibit B - Supplemental Historical Assessment (LIB230183)

Exhibit C - Carmel Unincorporated/Highlands LUAC Minutes (June 5, 2023)

Exhibit D - Carmel Unincorporated/Highlands LUAC Minutes (July 17, 2023)

Exhibit E - Public Comment

 

cc: Front Counter Copy; Planning Commission; California Coastal Commission; Carmel Highlands Fire Protection District; Environmental Health Bureau; HCD-Engineering Services Works; HCD-Environmental Services; Anna Ginette Quenga, AICP, Principal Planner; Fionna Jensen, Project Planner; Anna Bornstein, Agent; Adam Jeselnick, Agent; Carmel Assistant Living LLC, Owner; Laborers International Union of North America (Lozeau Drury LLP); The Open Monterey Project (Molly Erickson); LandWatch; Planning File PLN220212