Legislation Details

File #: PC 22-027    Name: PLN210113 - COPELAND
Type: Planning Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 4/1/2022 In control: County of Monterey Planning Commission
On agenda: 4/13/2022 Final action:
Title: PLN210113 - COPELAND Public hearing to consider allowing the construction of a 4,570 square foot two-story single family residence and an attached 2,175 square foot garage inclusive of storage area. The permit includes development in the "VS" Visually Sensitive Zoning District and the removal of 26 protected Oak trees. Project Location: 5501 Quail Meadows Drive, Carmel Valley (Assessor's Parcel Number 157-171-056-000) Carmel Valley, Carmel Valley Master Plan. Proposed CEQA Action: Find that project qualifies for a Class 3 Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15303 of the CEQA Guidelines.
Attachments: 1. Staff Report.pdf, 2. Exhibit A - Detailed Discussion.pdf, 3. Exhibit B - Draft Resolution.pdf, 4. Exhibit C - Vicinity Map.pdf, 5. Exhibit D - Carmel Valley LUAC minutes 2-7-22.pdf, 6. Exhibit E - Arborist Report.pdf

Title

PLN210113 - COPELAND

Public hearing to consider allowing the construction of a 4,570 square foot two-story single family residence and an attached 2,175 square foot garage inclusive of storage area. The permit includes development in the “VS” Visually Sensitive Zoning District and the removal of 26 protected Oak trees.

 

Project Location: 5501 Quail Meadows Drive, Carmel Valley (Assessor's Parcel Number 157-171-056-000) Carmel Valley, Carmel Valley Master Plan.

Proposed CEQA Action:  Find that project qualifies for a Class 3 Categorical Exemption  pursuant to Section 15303 of the CEQA Guidelines.

Report

RECOMMENDATIONS:

It is recommended that the Planning Commission:

a.  Find that the project qualifies as a Class 3 Categorical Exemption pursuant to Section 15303 of the CEQA Guidelines and there are no exceptions to the exemption: and

b.  Approve a Combined Development Permit consisting of:

1)    Administrative Permit and Design Approval to allow construction of a 4,570 square foot two-story single family residence, an attached 2,175 square foot garage and storage area, and associated grading consists of 300 cubic yards of cut and 300 cubic yards of fill;

2)    Administrative Permit to allow development in the “VS” Visually Sensitive Zoning District; and

3)    Use Permit to allow removal of 26 protected Oak trees.

 

A draft resolution, including findings and evidence, is attached for consideration (Exhibit B).  Staff recommends approval subject to eleven (11) conditions.

 

PROJECT INFORMATION:

Property Owner:  Ewan and Evelyn Copeland

Agent:  Holdren & Lietzke Architecture

APN:  157-171-056-000

Zoning:  LDR/B-6-VS-RAZ(20’) - Low Density Residential, with Building Site, Visual Sensitivity and Residential Allocation Zoning District Overlays

Parcel Size:  413,820 sq. ft.

Plan Area: Carmel Valley Land Use Plan

Flagged and Staked:  Yes

 

 

SUMMARY:

The property owners, Ewan and Evelyn Copeland, propose to construct a 4,570 square foot two-story single family residence and an attached 2,175 square foot garage and storage area on a vacant 9.5 acre property at 5501 Quail Meadows Drive, Carmel. The site is located near the intersection of Rancho San Carlos Road and Valley Greens Circle in the Quail Meadows subdivision. The vacant parcel contains a knoll that sits above the residential development between Carmel Valley Road and is near the entry to the Quail Meadows subdivision. A conservation and scenic easement was placed on the hill top and the north facing slope of the hill side on this property where development could be visible from Carmel Valley Road and residential neighborhoods near Carmel Valley Road and Rancho San Carlos Road. This proposed home will be located on the south facing slope near the ridge adjacent to the scenic easement boundary. In this area of the parcel, the home will be visible only within the Quail Meadows subdivision which includes private roads and development. The development was staked and flagged and the project planner conducted a site visit on December 2, 2021, to determine the potential for visual impacts. Due to the project siting, topography, vegetation and tree screening the proposed development will not have an adverse visual impact when viewed from common public viewing areas.


The project also proposes the removal of 25 protected Oak trees and 1 landmark Oak tree. The site is heavily forested and slopes up from the road to the top of the hill. Development of a conventional home anywhere on this lot would require tree removal.  Within the footprint of the house, driveway, and garage/storage, 25 oak trees, including 1 landmark oak tree will need to be removed. Attempts have been made to preserve other landmark oak trees near the building site. A Tree Assessment (LIB210224) was submitted for this project from Maureen Hamb. The report confirms that tree removal is limited to only those trees within the footprint of the proposed home and no significant fragmentation will occur within the oak woodland as a result of the project. Replacement of Oak trees at a 1:1 ratio was recommended. Staff suggests that replanting the one landmark tree at a 2:1 basis should be included for a total of 27 trees to be replanted at the site. The County has applied Condition No. 9, Tree and Root Protection, to ensure that all trees located near the project site that are not proposed for removal are protected during construction.  Condition No. 10, Tree Replacement, requires replanting 27 oak trees on the site.

 

There is an existing gravel path driveway that will be paved for access to the proposed single family dwelling. The driveway would require a small amount of grading, and overall a total of 220 square feet of area containing slopes over 25 percent will be impacted. Pursuant to OS-3-5, of the Monterey County General Plan, where proposed development impacting slopes in excess of 25% does not exceed ten percent or 500 square feet of the total development footprint, a discretionary permit shall not be required. In this case, the project does not include a use permit for development on slopes in excess of 25 percent because the impacts will be less than 500 square feet and less than 10% of the total developed area.

 

The Design of the proposed home is in keeping with character of the site and surrounding. Stained vertical wood siding with stone veneer elements and a standing seam metal roof are proposed. The design will be modern yet rustic, will meet all the site development standards including the 20 foot maximum heigh limit, and will be compatible with other residences in the vicinity.

 

DISCUSSION:

Please refer to Exhibit A for Detailed Discussion.

 

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW:

The project is categorically exempt from environmental review. California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15303 Class 3, categorically exempts the construction of single family dwellings (up to three) in residential zones. This project involves construction of a new single family dwelling in a residential zone. Therefore, the project is consistent with the parameters of the Class 3 categorical exemption.

None of the exceptions under CEQA Guidelines Section 15300.2 apply to this project.  The project does not involve a designated historical resource, a hazardous waste site, or unusual circumstances that would result in a significant effect. The results of the Archaeological report submitted for this project were negative for archaeological resources. The project also includes conditions of approval to protect archaeological resources in the event they are found during construction activities. The project as proposed would not be visible within public viewing areas- which in Carmel Valley include Garland Ranch Regional Park, Carmel Valley Road, and Laureles Road. No significant impacts to oak woodland are anticipated as the over 9.2 acres on 9.5 acre parcel will remain undisturbed and a large portion of that area is already protected within a conservation and scenic easement established when the subdivision was created. Therefore, the project does not involve unusual circumstances that would result in a significant effect or development that would result in a cumulative significant impact.

 

OTHER AGENCY INVOLVEMENT:

The following agencies have reviewed the project, have comments, and/or have recommended conditions:

Environmental Health Bureau

Environmental Services

Public Works

      Monterey County Regional Fire Protection District

 

Land Use Advisory Committee

The proposed project was reviewed by the Carmel Valley Land Use Advisory Committee (LUAC) on February 7, 2022.  The LUAC voted 5 - 0 to support the project as proposed. A member of LUAC raised a concern with the potential for light glare due to the proposed skylight. The LUAC also preferred a higher tree replacement ratio rather than the 1-1 ratio. Staff has reviewed the LUAC recommendations and suggests a lighting plan that includes shielding light from the skylight as a condition of approval and has increased the number of trees to be replanted from 26 to 27 to comply with tree preservation policies.

 

Prepared by:                     Sandra Villatoro, Assistant Planner, x55139

Reviewed by:                     Craig Spencer, Chief of Planning

Approved by:                     Erik Lundquist, AICP, Director of Housing & Community Development

 

The following attachments are on file with the HCD:

Exhibit A - Detailed Discussion

Exhibit B - Draft Resolution, including:

•                     Recommended Conditions of Approval

•                     Project Plans

Exhibit C - Vicinity Map

Exhibit D - Carmel Valley LUAC minutes for 2/7/22

Exhibit E - Arborist Report

 

cc: Front Counter Copy; California Coastal Commission; Erik Lundquist , HCD                      Director, Craig Spencer, HCD Chief of Planning; Sandra Villatoro, Project Planner;                      Public Works; Environmental Health Bureau; Environmental Services; the Monterey                      County Regional Fire Protection District, Ewan and Evelyn Copeland, Applicant/Owner;                      Brittney Olsen, Agent; The Open Monterey Project (Molly Erickson); LandWatch                      (Director); Project File PLN210113