Legislation Details

File #: PC 23-065    Name: PLN220073 – NGUYEN DIEM THI TR ET AL
Type: Planning Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 7/27/2023 In control: County of Monterey Planning Commission
On agenda: 8/30/2023 Final action:
Title: PLN220073 - NGUYEN DIEM THI TR ET AL Consider allowing transient occupancy for remuneration of an existing residence. Project Location: 960 Laureles Grade, Carmel Valley, CA 93924 Proposed CEQA action: Find that the project, allowing transient occupancy in an existing residence, qualifies for a Class 1 categorical exemption pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15301, and that none of the exceptions from section 15300.2 apply.
Attachments: 1. Staff Report, 2. Exhibit A - Draft Resolution, 3. Exhibit B – July 17, 2023 Carmel Valley LUAC Minutes, 4. Exhibit C – April 11, 2023 Site Visit Photos, 5. Exhibit D – Vicinity Map, 6. RESpc_23-031_PLN220073_083023

Title

PLN220073 - NGUYEN DIEM THI TR ET AL

Consider allowing transient occupancy for remuneration of an existing residence.

Project Location: 960 Laureles Grade, Carmel Valley, CA 93924

Proposed CEQA action: Find that the project, allowing transient occupancy in an existing residence, qualifies for a Class 1 categorical exemption pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15301, and that none of the exceptions from section 15300.2 apply.

Report

RECOMMENDATIONS

It is recommended that the Planning Commission adopt a resolution to:

a.  Find that the project, allowing transient occupancy for remuneration of an existing residence, qualifies for a Class 1 categorical exemption pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15301, and that none of the exceptions from section 15300.2 apply; and

b. Approve an Administrative Permit to allow transient use of an existing 5,754 square foot single-family residence for remuneration.

 

The attached draft resolution includes findings and evidence for consideration (Exhibit A). Staff recommends approval subject to 7 conditions of approval.

 

PROJECT INFORMATION

Applicant: Ivan Chen and Diem Nguyen

APN: 151-011-057-000

Parcel Size: 10.75 acres

Zoning: Low Density Residential with a density of 5 acres a unit, and Design Control, Site Plan Review, and Residential Allocation Zoning overlays, or “LDR/5-D-S-RAZ”

Plan Area: Carmel Valley Master Plan

Flagged and Staked: No

Project Planner: Phil Angelo, Associate Planner

                                                               (831) 784-5731 or angelop@co.monterey.ca.us

 

SUMMARY/DISCUSSION

The project proposes allowing transient occupancy for remuneration, or a short term rental, in an existing residence on a 10.75 acre residential property west of Laureles grade. This use is allowable subject to an Administrative Permit. Title 21 section 21.70.030 designates either the Chief of Planning or Zoning Administrator to be the appropriate authority to act on Administrative Permits. However, if there is evidence of public controversy an Administrative Permit it can be referred to a public hearing before the Zoning Administrator. In turn, if either the Chief of Planning or the Zoning Administrator determine that a project involves significant public policy issues at any point in the process, they may refer it to the Planning Commission (Title 21 section 21.04.030.F.). On March 21, 2023, due to ongoing public controversy regarding short-term rentals, the Board of Supervisors determined that all short-term rental applications within supervisorial District 5 were matters of public policy significance. Therefore, the project is being brought to the Planning Commission as the appropriate authority to act on the permit.

 

The site is developed with a 5,754 square foot single-family residence with an attached 2-car garage, a detached barn, a detached 4-car garage, and associated site improvements including hardscaping, a pool, an existing onsite wastewater treatment system, and an existing domestic well. The property has driveway access to Laureles grade through an existing 30 foot road and utilities easement depicted on Volume 33 of Surveys Pg. 23.

 

As demonstrated in the proposed Operations Plan (Exhibit A), the minimum rental period will be no less than 7 days and a maximum of no greater than 30 with a maximum total of 300 rental days per year. There will be a maximum of 12 guests in the 6 bedroom home and a total of 10 employees to provide property management, cleaning, landscape and pool services. Therefore, the proposed Operations Plan complies with the requirements for transient occupancy for remuneration codified in Title 21 section 21.64.280. The site appears suitable for the proposed use, and no circumstances were identified in the review that would indicate that the use at this specific site would be injurious to the health or general welfare of those residing or working in the County.

 

Staff are recommending Condition No. 6, which would place a time limitation on the use of 3-years, after which an extension would need to be applied for and approved for the use to continue operating. The time limitation allows the County to ensure that the use continues to meet the standards of Title 21, that the character of the area has not changed so to cause the transient use to be detrimental to the area, and to review ongoing compliance with the permits conditions of approval. The 3-year duration is consistent with projects the Planning Commission have recently approved. The chapter on Administrative Permits, Chapter 21.70, specifically authorizes the appropriate authority to apply conditions it deems necessary to secure the purposes of the Zoning Ordinance, including time limitations and review to assure conditions are met (Title 21 section 21.70.050.E.).

 

OTHER DEPARTMENT/AGENCY INVOLVEMENT

The following County departments and other agencies have reviewed the project:

HCD-Planning Services;

HCD-Engineering Services;

Environmental Health Bureau;

HCD-Environmental Services; and the Monterey County Regional Fire Protection District.

 

LUAC

The project was referred to the Carmel Valley Land Use Advisory Committee (LUAC), who reviewed the project and recommended approval as proposed on July 17, 2023. LUAC member John Heyl asked whether the owner would be renting the property (rather than a commercial enterprise or management company). Owners Ivan Chen and Diem Nguyen were present and confirmed that they would be renting the property.

 

CEQA

The project qualifies for a Class 1 categorical exemption pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15301 and no unusual circumstances were identified to exist for the proposed project. California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines section 15301, categorically exempts the leasing of existing private structures, involving negligible or no expansion of existing or former use. The project proposes transient occupancy of an existing residence for remuneration, which would allow leasing of the residential property for shorter stays (between 7-30 days). The project would expand the residence or allow additional occupancy beyond what would be allowed for the existing residence. Therefore, the project fits the criteria of the exemption.

 

None of the exceptions under CEQA Guidelines section 15300.2 apply to this project:

•                     Class 1 exemptions are not qualified for an exception by their location.

•                     The County’s regulatory process of Administrative Permits for transient occupancy for remuneration allows the County to regulate such uses in a way that would prevent adverse cumulative impacts to the surrounding environment, consistent with the Finding and Declaration in Title 21 section 21.64.280.A.6. The project is consistent with all the criteria of Title 21 section 21.64.280, and therefore would not contribute to a cumulative effect.

•                     There are no unusual circumstances related to the project that would create the reasonable possibility of a significant effect.

•                     The project would not result to damage to scenic resources within view of State Scenic Highway. The project does not include any physical changes that could damage scenic resources: no construction, exterior alterations to structures, land alteration, or vegetation (or tree) removal are proposed.

•                     The project is not located on a hazardous waste site included on any list compiled pursuant to Section 65962.5 of the Government code.

•                     The project would not damage any historical resources.

 

Prepared by:                     Phil Angelo, Associate Planner, x5731

Reviewed by:                     Anna Ginette Quenga, AICP, Principal Planner

Approved by: Craig Spencer, Chief of Planning

 

The following attachments are on file with HCD:

Exhibit A - Draft Resolution including:

•                     Recommended Conditions of Approval

•                     Site Plans and Floor Plans

•                     Operations Plan

Exhibit B - July 17, 2023 Carmel Valley LUAC Minutes

Exhibit C - April 11, 2023 Site Visit Photos

Exhibit D - Vicinity Map

 

cc: Front Counter Copy; Monterey County Regional Fire Protection District; HCD-Environmental Services; HCD-Engineering Services; Environmental Health Bureau; Phil Angelo, Associate Planner, x5731; Anna Quenga, AICP, Principal Planner; Ivan Chen, Applicant; Diem Nguyen, Applicant; The Open Monterey Project; Lozeau Dury LLP; LandWatch (Executive Director); Planning File PLN220073