File #: RES 19-037    Name: PIETRO & VALLEY POINT - PLN170611 PLN170612 PLN170613
Type: BoS Resolution Status: Passed - RMA Land Use and Community Development
File created: 4/12/2019 In control: Board of Supervisors
On agenda: 4/23/2019 Final action:
Title: PLN170611 & PLN170612 (PIETRO FAMILY INVESTMENTS LP) & PLN170613 (VALLEY POINT LLC) Public Hearing (continued from March 12 and 26, 2019) to consider the appeal by Open Monterey Project and Save Carmel Point Cultural Resources of the December 5, 2018 Planning Commission decisions: a. Approving a Combined Development Permit (PLN170611) to allow construction of a single-family dwelling, attached garage, and basement within 750 feet of known archaeological resources at 26307 Isabella Avenue (APN: 009-463-012-000); b. Approving a Combined Development Permit (PLN170612) to allow construction of a single-family dwelling, attached garage, and basement within 750 feet of known archaeological resources, including abatement of a code enforcement case, at 26338 Valley View Avenue (APN: 009-463-017-000); and c. Approving a Combined Development Permit (PLN170612) to allow construction of a single-family dwelling, attached garage, and basement within 750 feet of known archaeological resources, inclu...
Attachments: 1. Board Report, 2. Attachment A - Discussion, 3. Attachment B - Map of the Subj Parcels & Glossary, 4. Attachment C1 - Draft Resolution PLN170611, 5. Attachment C2 - Draft Resolution PLN170612 & PLN170613, 6. Attachment D - PC Resolutions, 7. Attachment E - Notice of Appeal 1-14-19, 8. Attachment F - IS-MND PLN170611, 9. Attachment G - IS-MND PLN170612 & PLN170613, 10. Attachment H - Carmel Highlands LUAC Minutes, 11. Attachment I - Correspondence re IS & Mitigations, 12. Attachment J - Technical Reports PLN170611, 13. Attachment K - Technical Reports PLN170612, 14. Attachment L - Technical Reports PLN170613, 15. Attachment M - Correspondence for CA Coastal Commission, 16. Attachment N - Correspondence Molly Erickson, 17. Attachment O - Correspondence Public Comment, 18. Attachment P - Correspondence NAHC, 19. Attachment Q - Correspondence OCEN, 20. Attachment R - Correspondence Applicant Submittals, 21. Completed Board Order, Resolution 19-121 & 19-122 for PLN170611, PLN170612, PLN170613 & Conditions of Approval/Implementation Plan/Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan, 22. Item No. 17 Revised Board Resolution No. 19-122
Title
PLN170611 & PLN170612 (PIETRO FAMILY INVESTMENTS LP) & PLN170613 (VALLEY POINT LLC)
Public Hearing (continued from March 12 and 26, 2019) to consider the appeal by Open Monterey Project and Save Carmel Point Cultural Resources of the December 5, 2018 Planning Commission decisions:
a. Approving a Combined Development Permit (PLN170611) to allow construction of a single-family dwelling, attached garage, and basement within 750 feet of known archaeological resources at 26307 Isabella Avenue (APN: 009-463-012-000);
b. Approving a Combined Development Permit (PLN170612) to allow construction of a single-family dwelling, attached garage, and basement within 750 feet of known archaeological resources, including abatement of a code enforcement case, at 26338 Valley View Avenue (APN: 009-463-017-000); and
c. Approving a Combined Development Permit (PLN170612) to allow construction of a single-family dwelling, attached garage, and basement within 750 feet of known archaeological resources, including abatement of a code enforcement case, at 26346 Valley View Avenue (APN: 009-463-003-000).
Project Locations: These projects are located on Carmel Point in the Carmel Area Land Use Plan area
Proposed CEQA action: Adopt two Mitigated Negative Declarations, one prepared for PLN170611 and one prepared for both PLN170612 & PLN170613
Report
RECOMMENDATION:
It is recommended that the Board of Supervisors:
1) Adopt a resolution (Attachment C-1) to:
a) Deny the appeal by The Open Monterey Project and Save Carmel Point Cultural Resources challenging the Planning Commission's approval of a Combined Development Permit (PLN170611) to allow construction of a single-family dwelling, garage, and basement within 750 feet of known archaeological resources at 26307 Isabella Avenue;
b) Adopt a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) for the Project (PLN170611);
c) Approve a Combined Development Permit (PLN170611) at 26307 Isabella Avenue consisting of:
1. Coastal Administrative Permit and Des...

Click here for full text